The short answer: AquaTru is the better filter for removing contaminants, and Berkey is better only if you need filtration without electricity. The AquaTru Classic is certified by IAPMO under NSF/ANSI 58, 53, 401 and 42 for fluoride, lead, arsenic, nitrate, PFOA, PFOS, VOCs and microplastics. A Big Berkey with Phoenix Gravity elements is certified under NSF/ANSI 42 for chlorine and taste and odor only. The original Black Berkey elements have no NSF/ANSI certification, and the EPA has ordered them off the market as unregistered pesticide products, an order a federal appeals court let stand on September 18, 2026.

Prices on November 15, 2026: the AquaTru Classic is $380 on AquaTru’s Black Friday sale (was $475; $475 on Amazon). A Big Berkey with Phoenix elements was $267 on Amazon.

AquaTru vs. Berkey at a Glance

AquaTru ClassicBig Berkey (Phoenix Gravity elements)
TypeCountertop reverse osmosis, 4 stagesGravity carbon filter, stainless steel
Certifier and standardsIAPMO R&T: NSF/ANSI 58 (W-10194), 53 (W-10193), 401 (W-10195), 42 (W-10188)NSF: NSF/ANSI 42
Certified to reduceTDS, fluoride, lead, arsenic (pentavalent), nitrate/nitrite, barium, chromium, copper, radium, selenium, cysts, perchlorate; PFOA, PFOS, VOCs; microplastics and 15 emerging compounds; chlorine, chloramineChlorine; taste and odor
Lead, PFAS, fluorideCertifiedLab-tested only; fluoride needs add-on PF-2 elements (also not certified)
Capacity0.75 gal of purified water2.25 gal
Output54 gallons per dayDepends on number of elements and water level
Electricity120 V outletNone
Waste waterAbout 1/3 gal per gallon (75% efficiency)None
MineralsRemoves mostLeaves most in
Filter lifePre/carbon 600 gal, VOC 600 gal, RO 1,200 galPhoenix pair: 1,050 gal NSF service cycle
Filter costAbout $0.17 per gallon; about $130 a yearPhoenix pair $120 on Amazon, about $0.11 per gallon at 1,050 gal
Price, Nov. 15, 2026$380 on sale (was $475)$267 on Amazon

Certifications are from IAPMO R&T’s AquaTru listings and NSF’s listing for New Millennium Concepts, both current on November 15, 2026.

Certification: The Main Difference

AquaTru’s claims are backed by four IAPMO certificates. Under NSF/ANSI 58, the Classic is certified for TDS, fluoride, lead, arsenic, nitrate/nitrite and seven more; under NSF/ANSI 53 for PFOA, PFOS and VOCs; under NSF/ANSI 401 for microplastics and 15 emerging compounds such as BPA and ibuprofen.

Berkey’s certification is much narrower. NSF lists the Big, Royal and Travel Berkey with Phoenix Gravity New Millennium Edition elements (PGF9-2) under NSF/ANSI 42 for chlorine reduction and taste and odor reduction, with a 1,050-gallon service cycle. That’s an aesthetic standard. Neither Phoenix nor the older Black Berkey elements are certified under NSF/ANSI 53 or 58 for lead, PFAS, fluoride or anything else that affects health. Berkey’s published lab reports test many contaminants, but a lab report isn’t a certification: no certifier audits the product or re-tests it.

The EPA and Black Berkey Elements

Black Berkey elements contain silver, which the EPA treats as a pesticide when a product claims to kill or remove germs. The EPA found that Berkey International and its distributors marketed the filters as removing bacteria and viruses without registering them, and issued Stop Sale, Use, or Removal Orders. Berkey sued. On September 18, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit affirmed the denial of Berkey’s request for a preliminary injunction, holding that the EPA had reason to believe the filters were unregistered and misbranded pesticide products.

The result for buyers: Black Berkey replacement elements aren’t normally available in the US, and Phoenix Gravity elements, endorsed by Berkey’s maker New Millennium Concepts, are sold as the replacement. If you already own a Black Berkey, check the current guidance for your elements before buying replacements.

Fluoride, Arsenic and PFAS

If any of these is why you’re buying a filter, AquaTru is the one with certified claims. IAPMO certifies the Classic for fluoride and arsenic under NSF/ANSI 58 and for PFOA and PFOS under NSF/ANSI 53.

Berkey’s main elements don’t target fluoride. Berkey sells separate PF-2 elements that thread under the main elements for fluoride and arsenic, tested by lab but not certified. Its PFAS results are also lab reports, not certifications.

Capacity, Power and Waste

Berkey’s advantages are real. A Big Berkey holds 2.25 gallons, runs on gravity with no electricity, wastes no water, and leaves minerals in. That makes it useful for camping, power outages and off-grid homes, as long as the source water is treated municipal water; the Phoenix guidance covers treated municipal water, not untreated well, lake or stream water.

The AquaTru Classic needs an outlet, stores 0.75 gallons and sends about a third of a gallon of reject water to its tap tank for every gallon it purifies. It’s faster to get a glass: it filters a tank in about 20 minutes, while a gravity filter’s speed depends on how full the upper chamber is. Our countertop RO waste water guide covers RO waste in detail.

Filter Costs

Berkey’s Phoenix elements are cheaper per gallon: $120 a pair on Amazon for a 1,050-gallon NSF service cycle, about $0.11 per gallon. AquaTru’s filters cost about $0.17 per gallon at their rated lives, or about $130 a year bought individually. The AquaTru filters do far more for the money. For other RO brands, see our countertop RO filter cost comparison.

Which Should You Buy?

If you…Better pickWhy
Want certified lead, fluoride, arsenic or PFAS reductionAquaTru ClassicThe only one of the two certified for them
Need filtration without powerBig BerkeyGravity-fed, no outlet
Want no waste waterBig BerkeyNo reject stream
Want to keep minerals in the waterBig BerkeyCarbon filtration leaves them
Mainly want better-tasting city waterEitherBoth certified for chlorine taste and odor
Own Black Berkey elementsCheck replacements firstBlack Berkey elements are under EPA stop-sale orders

Best for certified filtration

AquaTru Classic

IAPMO certified for fluoride, lead, arsenic, PFOA/PFOS, VOCs and microplastics.

Best without electricity

Big Berkey with Phoenix Elements

2.25-gallon gravity filter, NSF/ANSI 42 certified for chlorine and taste with Phoenix elements.

For other countertop RO picks, see our guide to the best countertop reverse osmosis systems, and for the AquaTru line, AquaTru Classic vs. Carafe.

AquaTru vs. Berkey FAQ

Is AquaTru better than Berkey?

For contaminant removal, yes. The AquaTru Classic is IAPMO certified for fluoride, lead, arsenic, nitrate, PFOA, PFOS, VOCs and microplastics. A Phoenix-equipped Berkey is certified only for chlorine and taste and odor. Berkey is better if you need a filter that works without electricity.

Is Berkey NSF certified?

Only partly. NSF lists the Big, Royal and Travel Berkey with Phoenix Gravity elements under NSF/ANSI 42 for chlorine and taste and odor reduction. Black Berkey elements have no NSF/ANSI certification, and no Berkey element is certified for lead, PFAS or fluoride.

Why can’t I buy Black Berkey filters?

The EPA issued stop-sale orders treating Black Berkey elements, which contain silver, as unregistered pesticide products. On September 18, 2026, the First Circuit affirmed the denial of Berkey’s request to block enforcement. Phoenix Gravity elements are sold as the replacement.

Does Berkey remove fluoride?

Not with its main elements. Berkey sells add-on PF-2 elements for fluoride and arsenic, supported by lab tests but not certified. The AquaTru Classic is certified under NSF/ANSI 58 for fluoride reduction.

Is countertop reverse osmosis better than a Berkey?

For most homes, yes: certified countertop RO systems reduce more health-related contaminants. A Berkey wins for off-grid use, no waste water and keeping minerals in the water.

Which costs less to run?

Berkey’s Phoenix elements, at about $0.11 per gallon over their 1,050-gallon NSF service cycle. AquaTru’s filters cost about $0.17 per gallon.