Finding the perfect pillow can completely change how you sleep, but it’s not always easy to get right. That’s why we tested a wide range of options to find the best bed pillows for support, comfort, and durability. We focused on neck support, shape retention through the night, and breathability to keep you cool and comfortable.
We also paid close attention to details like stitching quality, chemical odors, and how well the covers held in their filling. Since pillows can be a highly personal choice, we gave extra points to those with generous return policies and solid warranties, so you can rest easy knowing you’re covered if it’s not the right fit.
Nest Bedding Easy Breather Pillow
Best Overall Pillow
A highly adjustable shredded-foam pillow with a soft, washable cover and inner pouch. Great for those who want personalized loft and firm support.
Buy on AmazonThe Nest Bedding Easy Breather Pillow stands out for its firm, customizable support and overall comfort. It uses high-quality shredded memory foam that avoids the lingering chemical smell often found in similar pillows. The foam fill provides a balance of softness and support, helping to maintain spinal alignment throughout the night.
What sets the Easy Breather apart is its thoughtful construction. The shredded foam is enclosed in a zippered, washable inner pouch, allowing you to adjust the loft by adding or removing fill. While this can be a bit messy, it offers a level of customization that most pillows don’t. The outer cover is soft, breathable, and also machine washable. Available in four sizes, including a curved-edge version designed for side sleepers, the Easy Breather includes a 30-day return policy and a two-year warranty, giving you time to make sure it’s the right fit.
Coop Eden Pillow
Best for side & back sleepers
This pillow combines quality materials, optimal comfort, and snug support to deliver great sleep. And it offers plenty of neck support for back and side-sleepers.
Buy on AmazonThe Coop Home Goods Eden Pillow is a premium shredded-foam option that combines adjustability, quality materials, and thoughtful construction. Its fill, made of gel-infused memory foam and plush microfiber, delivers a balance of softness and support, while the gusseted edges help keep that fill evenly distributed throughout the night. The outer cover, made from Lulltra fabric (a blend of polyester and bamboo-derived viscose rayon), has a soft, velvety feel and can be used without a pillowcase. A hidden zipper gives access to the fill, allowing you to adjust the loft to suit your sleeping position.
The Eden maintains a neutral sleeping temperature, thanks to its breathable construction and cooling gel-infused foam, though it may still feel a bit warm over time for hot sleepers. It’s GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US certified, ensuring low chemical emissions and high safety standards. With a 5-year warranty and a fully washable cover, the Coop Eden is ideal for sleepers who want a durable, supportive, and highly customizable pillow, especially those who switch positions or prefer a firmer feel that doesn’t lose shape.
Xtreme Comforts Shredded Memory Foam Pillow
Best Budget Pillow
A supportive, moldable shredded-foam pillow at a budget-friendly price. Its medium loft and adjustability make it a good fit for all sleep positions.
Buy on AmazonThe Xtreme Comforts Shredded Memory Foam Pillow is a reliable and affordable option that offers adaptable support for a wide range of sleep positions. With a medium loft and moldable shredded memory foam fill, it contours well to the head and neck, making it a solid choice for side, back, and even some stomach sleepers. Its adjustability allows you to reshape it for personalized comfort, which can help with alignment and reduce pressure points.
Although past versions of this pillow were known to occasionally carry a strong chemical odor, more recent batches appear to have resolved this issue, with fewer reports of off-putting smells. The Xtreme Comforts pillow typically costs significantly less than many high-end competitors and includes a 30-day return policy, making it a low-risk option for those looking to try a shredded-foam pillow without committing to a higher price point.
No matter your sleep style or budget, the right pillow can make a noticeable difference in how rested you feel each morning. Whether you prefer firm support, a soft and airy feel, or something in between, each of our top picks offers something unique, along with return policies and warranties that give you peace of mind while you try them out.
From the highly adjustable Nest Easy Breather to the plush-yet-supportive Coop Eden and the affordable, versatile Xtreme Comforts Pillow, these options cover a wide range of preferences. A great night’s sleep starts with the right foundation, and investing in the right pillow is one of the simplest ways to upgrade your rest.