The short answer: if you can have only one, buy a microwave; it reheats, defrosts and cooks liquids faster than anything else in the kitchen. A toaster oven is the better second appliance if you want toast, melted-and-browned tops, crisp reheated pizza or small-batch baking. If space allows only one appliance and you need both, a convection microwave combo does both jobs, with some compromise: Toshiba’s 1.5 cu ft ML-EC42P was $219.99 on November 19, 2026.

Prices checked November 19, 2026.

Microwave vs. Toaster Oven at a Glance

JobMicrowaveToaster oven
Reheat soup, rice, pasta, coffeeBetterSlow; dries food
DefrostBetter (defrost setting or 30% power)Not designed for it
Toast, bagelsCan’tBetter
Reheat pizza, fries, fried foodSoggyBetter (crisp)
Brown cheese, roast vegetablesCan’t brownBetter
Bake cookies, small casserolesOnly convection modelsYes
Popcorn, steaming vegetablesBetterNo
Typical input powerAbout 1,000–1,550 WUp to 1,800 W on larger models
PreheatNoneA few minutes

Why They Cook So Differently

A microwave heats the water in food directly. USDA’s guidance says microwaves “penetrate the food to a depth of 1 to 1½ inches,” and the heat spreads inward from there. Nothing heats the air or the walls, so there’s no browning or crisping, but there’s also no preheat and very little wasted energy. FDA puts it this way: “Microwave cooking can be more energy efficient than conventional cooking because foods cook faster and the energy heats only the food, not the whole oven compartment.”

A toaster oven is a small electric oven: heating elements warm the air and radiate onto the food surface, which dries and browns it. That’s what makes toast, crisp crusts and golden cheese, and it’s why toaster ovens are slower for anything thick or watery.

Power and Energy Use

ApplianceInput powerSource
Panasonic NN-SN67KS microwave (1,200 W cooking)1,480 WOwner’s manual
Toshiba EM131A5C microwave (1,100 W cooking)1,550 WOwner’s manual
Breville BMO850 microwave (1,200 W cooking)1,250 WManual
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro (toaster oven)1,800 WOur review

For a 3-minute reheat, a 1,500 W microwave uses about 0.075 kWh, roughly 1.4 cents at the US average residential price of 18.16 cents per kWh (EIA, August 2026). A toaster oven drawing 1,800 W for a 5-minute preheat plus 10 minutes of heating uses about 0.45 kWh at full draw, though thermostats cycle the elements once they’re up to temperature. For reheating, the microwave is cheaper to run. Full math in how much electricity a microwave uses.

The Third Option: A Convection Microwave

If one appliance has to do both, a convection microwave adds a heating element and fan to a microwave, so it can bake, roast and (on most new models) air fry. It browns less well than a good toaster oven’s top elements and costs more than a basic microwave, but it replaces both.

ModelCapacityMicrowave powerOven modesPrice (Nov 19)
GE GCST10A1WSS1.0 cu ft1,050 WConvection, broil, air fry$199.00 on Amazon
Toshiba ML-EC42P(SS)1.5 cu ft1,000 WConvection, air fry, grill$219.99 on Amazon
Breville Combi Wave BMO8701.1 cu ft1,100 WConvection 100–450°F, air fry, grill$499.95 on Amazon

See convection microwave vs. regular microwave for the trade-offs.

One appliance for both jobs

Toshiba ML-EC42P(SS)

1.5 cu ft, 1,000 W microwave with convection, air fry and grill modes for baking and crisping.

Simple microwave pick

Toshiba EM131A5C-SS

1.2 cu ft microwave with a humidity sensor and 12.4-inch turntable; 1,100 W output per its manual.

Which Should You Buy?

  • Microwave if you reheat leftovers and drinks, defrost, and cook frozen meals. It’s the one appliance most kitchens can’t do without. Picks: the best microwaves.
  • Toaster oven as a second appliance if you toast daily, reheat pizza and fried food, or bake small batches without heating a full oven.
  • Convection microwave if you have room for only one and want both. Picks: the best convection microwaves.

FAQ

Should I buy a microwave or a toaster oven?

If you can only have one, buy a microwave: it reheats and defrosts far faster and handles liquids a toaster oven can’t. Add a toaster oven later if you want toast, crisp reheating and small-batch baking.

Can a toaster oven replace a microwave?

Not well. It can reheat solid foods and bake, but it’s slow for soups and drinks, can’t defrost properly, and needs preheating.

Which uses less electricity, a microwave or a toaster oven?

For reheating, the microwave. It runs for a few minutes and heats only the food; FDA notes microwaves can be more energy efficient because the energy “heats only the food, not the whole oven compartment.”

Is there an appliance that does both?

Yes. A convection microwave adds a heating element and fan to a microwave. Toshiba’s ML-EC42P and Breville’s Combi Wave are examples, at $219.99 and $499.95 on Amazon on November 19, 2026.

Can you reheat pizza in a microwave?

You can, but the crust softens. A toaster oven or air fryer re-crisps it; see microwave vs. air fryer for reheating.

Sources