The short answer: use the microwave for anything wet (soup, rice, pasta, stews, curries, mashed potatoes) and the air fryer for anything that should be crisp (pizza, fries, wings, breaded chicken, pastries). The microwave heats the water inside food, which is fast and keeps moist food moist but turns crusts soft. The air fryer blows hot air over the surface, which re-crisps crusts but dries out sauces. Whichever you use, USDA says leftovers should reach 165°F.

Food-by-Food Guide

LeftoverBest applianceWhy
Soup, chili, stewMicrowaveLiquids heat fast; an air fryer can’t hold them
RiceMicrowaveAdd a splash of water and cover so it steams
Pasta with sauceMicrowaveSauce stays loose; stir halfway
Casseroles, lasagnaMicrowave (reduced power)Dense centers need time; lower power avoids hard edges
Mashed potatoes, vegetables in sauceMicrowaveMoisture matters more than crispness
PizzaAir fryerRe-crisps the crust; microwave makes it chewy
French fries, tater totsAir fryerMicrowaved fries go limp
Fried or breaded chicken, wingsAir fryerRestores the crust
Roasted vegetablesAir fryerRe-browns edges
Pastries, croissants, egg rollsAir fryerFlaky layers soften in a microwave
Steak, roast meatEither, gentlyMicrowave at 50% covered, or air fryer briefly; both can overcook it

Why the Results Differ

Microwave: microwaves penetrate food “to a depth of 1 to 1½ inches,” according to USDA, heating the water in it. Steam is trapped in breading and crusts, which is why they turn soft. Nothing browns. The upside is speed and even moisture for wet foods, especially covered.

Air fryer: a heating element and fan blow hot air over the surface. The outside heats first and dries, which re-crisps fried and baked food. The inside warms more slowly, and liquids and sauces can’t be heated in a basket.

Getting Microwave Reheating Right

USDA’s microwave guidance covers what makes reheating safe and even:

  • Cover and vent. “Cover the dish with a lid or plastic wrap… Loosen or vent the lid or wrap to allow steam to vent.”
  • Stir or turn halfway. “Stir, rotate, or turn foods upside down (where possible) midway through the microwaving time.” Do this even with a turntable.
  • Let it stand. “After reheating foods in the microwave oven, allow standing time. Then, use a clean food thermometer to check that food has reached 165 °F.”
  • Use lower power for dense food. A casserole at 50% to 70% for longer heats through without hard edges. Inverter microwaves do this more smoothly; see inverter vs. non-inverter.
  • Sensor reheat helps. Microwaves with a humidity or steam sensor (Panasonic Genius, Toshiba humidity sensor, LG’s sensor reheat options) stop when the food releases enough steam. See the best microwaves for reheating and defrosting.

Getting Air Fryer Reheating Right

  • Use a moderate temperature (around 325–375°F) for a few minutes, and check early: reheating takes far less time than cooking.
  • Spread food in one layer so air reaches every side.
  • For pizza and pastries, a lower temperature keeps the top from burning before the center warms.
  • Check the center reaches 165°F for meat and dishes containing meat.

One Appliance for Both

A microwave air fryer combo can do either job, just not both at once. Its air fry mode is gentler than a basket fryer’s, but it handles pizza and fries well enough for many kitchens. Compare in microwave air fryer combo vs. air fryer.

Best microwave for reheating

Panasonic NN-SN67QS

1.2 cu ft, 1,250 W inverter with a Genius steam sensor that adjusts reheat time automatically; $199.95 on Amazon Nov 19, 2026.

Microwave and air fryer in one

Toshiba ML-EC42P(SS)

1.5 cu ft, 1,000 W microwave with air fry, convection and grill; $219.99 on Amazon Nov 19, 2026.

FAQ

Is it better to reheat food in a microwave or an air fryer?

It depends on the food. Microwave soups, rice, pasta, casseroles and saucy dishes; air fry pizza, fries, wings, breaded foods and pastries.

Why does microwaved pizza get soggy?

Microwaves heat the water in the crust and toppings, and the steam softens the crust. An air fryer or toaster oven dries and re-crisps the surface instead.

What temperature should reheated leftovers reach?

USDA says to check that reheated food reaches 165°F with a food thermometer, after a standing time.

Can you reheat soup in an air fryer?

Not practically. Air fryer baskets are perforated, and the dry heat is slow for liquids. Use the microwave or the stove.

Does an air fryer use more electricity than a microwave for reheating?

Usually, because it runs longer and heats air as well as food. A microwave reheats a plate in a few minutes; FDA notes microwave energy “heats only the food, not the whole oven compartment.” See how much electricity a microwave uses.

Sources