The short answer: buy a motorized toaster, so nobody has to push a spring-loaded lever down. The Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast ($199.95) lowers the bread at the press of a button and lifts it when done, with 1.5-inch slots and a front crumb tray. The Cuisinart CPT-525 ($99.95) does the same for half the price, with presets and saved settings, and the CPT-545 ($149.99) is its 4-slice version. If a lever is fine but small items are hard to grab, the KitchenAid KMT2115 ($47.99) has a manual high-lift lever.
Prices checked November 19, 2026, on Amazon.
What to Look For
| Feature | Why it helps | Models with it |
|---|---|---|
| Motorized lowering (no lever) | Nothing to press against a spring | Breville BTA820XL, BTA830XL, BTA840XL; Cuisinart CPT-525, CPT-545 |
| High lift | Raises English muffins and small slices clear of the slot, no tongs | KitchenAid KMT2115; Hamilton Beach 22633 (Toast Boost); Cuisinart CPT-160P1 and CPT-122 |
| Front crumb tray | No tipping or reaching behind the toaster | Breville Die-Cast |
| Big, simple controls | Fewer steps | Cuisinart CPT-525 Memory Set; Breville BTA735 presets |
| Window or Lift & Look | Check browning without lifting the bread out | Dash Clear View (window); Breville (Lift & Look) |
| Auto shutoff | Turns off if bread jams | Hamilton Beach 22633 |
Best Overall: Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast
Best for seniors
Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster
Press one button: a motor lowers the bread and raises it when done. Front crumb tray, 1.5 x 5.5 inch slots. $199.95.
There’s no lever on the Die-Cast. Press Toast and a motor lowers the bread into the slots; it rises on its own at the end. Lift & Look raises it to check the color, A Bit More adds time, and the crumb tray pulls out from the front. The slots are 1.5 x 5.5 inches, wide enough for bagels. The browning control is a slider rather than a knob. It costs $199.95 with a 1-year warranty.
Best Value: Cuisinart CPT-525
Best value motorized
Cuisinart CPT-525 2-Slice Motorized Digital Toaster
No lever: one touch lowers and raises the bread. 6 presets, 7 shades and Memory Set saves 4 settings. $99.95.
The CPT-525 lowers and raises the bread with one touch. Memory Set saves four settings, so a person can press one button for their usual toast instead of setting bread type and shade each time. High-Lift QuickView raises the bread to check it. Cuisinart’s 3-year limited warranty is three times Breville’s.
Best 4-Slice: Cuisinart CPT-545
Best 4-slice motorized
Cuisinart CPT-545 4-Slice Motorized Digital Toaster
4-slice version of the CPT-525: motorized lowering, bread presets, 7 shades and Memory Set. $149.99.
Cuisinart lists the same feature set as the CPT-525 in a 4-slice body. It costs about $100 less than Breville’s motorized 4-slice Die-Cast BTA840XL ($249.95 list).
Best With a Lever: KitchenAid KMT2115
Best with a lever
KitchenAid KMT2115SX 2-Slice Toaster
Manual high-lift lever raises small items clear of the slots. 1.5-inch slots, 5 shades, bagel and frozen. $47.99.
If pushing a lever down is fine but fishing out small items isn’t, the KMT2115’s manual high-lift lever raises English muffins and short slices above the slot. It has backlit buttons and 5 shades. KitchenAid replaces it, rather than repairing it, within the 1-year warranty.
Best Window: Dash Clear View
Best window
Dash Clear View Long Slot Toaster, Black
See-through glass window to watch browning without lifting the bread. 7 levels, bagel, defrost, reheat. $43.99.
A glass window on the side shows the bread browning, so there’s no need to lift it out to check. It has auto shut-off, 7 browning levels and a slide-out crumb tray. It has a standard lever.
Toasters for Seniors FAQ
What is the best toaster for someone with arthritis?
A motorized toaster with no lever: the Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast ($199.95) or the Cuisinart CPT-525 ($99.95). Both lower and raise the bread at the press of a button.
Does KitchenAid still make an automatic toaster?
KitchenAid’s Pro Line KMT2203 and KMT4203 lowered the bread automatically, but Abt lists the KMT2203 as no longer available and Walmart shows the KMT4203 out of stock. The motorized options in November 2026 are Breville’s Die-Cast line and Cuisinart’s CPT-525 and CPT-545.
Are toasters with auto shutoff safer?
Auto shutoff turns the elements off if the carriage stays down, for example when bread jams. Hamilton Beach lists it on the 22633. Any toaster should be unplugged when not in use, as most manuals advise. See toaster lever won’t stay down for a common fault.
What toaster is easiest to clean?
One with a front crumb tray, like the Breville Die-Cast, so you don’t have to turn or lift the toaster. See how to clean a toaster.










