The short answer: unplug the toaster and let it cool, empty the crumb tray, turn the toaster upside down over the trash and shake, then wipe the outside with a damp cloth. Never reach inside with a knife or fork, never use metal scouring pads, and never spray cleaner into the slots. For a toaster oven, also wipe the inside walls with a soft damp sponge, with any cleanser on the sponge rather than the oven, and clean the crumb tray after each use.

How to Clean a Pop-Up Toaster

  1. Unplug it and let it cool completely. Hamilton Beach and Breville both say not to dislodge food while the toaster is plugged in.
  2. Empty the crumb tray. On most toasters it drops down or slides out from the bottom, side or front (Breville’s is under the browning control at the front). Discard the crumbs and wipe the tray with a clean cloth.
  3. Shake out loose crumbs. Turn the toaster upside down over a trash can and shake. Hamilton Beach and Breville both give this step for crumbs and food stuck in the slots.
  4. Replace the crumb tray. Breville says not to use the toaster without it in place.
  5. Wipe the outside with a slightly damp, soft cloth and dry it. Hamilton Beach says not to use abrasive cleansers that may scratch the surface; Breville says to dry it completely with a soft dry cloth.
  6. Dry everything before plugging back in.

How often: Hamilton Beach says to clean the crumb tray weekly if you use the toaster daily. Breville warns that not cleaning it regularly “may result in a fire hazard and damage to the toaster,” and Revolution that crumb build-up “may result in a fire hazard.”

What Not to Use

Don’tWhy (maker manuals)
Knives, forks or other metal inside the slotsBreville: can “damage the heating elements as well as lead to electrocution.”
Metal scouring padsBreville: “Pieces can break off and touch electrical parts, creating a shock hazard.”
Harsh, abrasive or caustic cleaners and oven cleanerBreville and Hamilton Beach say not to use them.
Sprays or soakingRevolution: “do not spray directly or douse the toaster with any type of cleaner or solution… only use a cloth dampened by water.” Never immerse a toaster, cord or plug in water.
The dishwasherNo maker in our research says a toaster crumb tray is dishwasher safe; wipe it by hand.

How to Clean the Inside of a Toaster Oven

Steps from Breville’s Smart Oven (BOV800XL) manual; other ovens are similar, but check yours.

  1. Turn the oven off, unplug it and let it and the accessories cool completely.
  2. Slide out the crumb tray and discard crumbs. Breville says to do this after each use. Wipe the tray with a soft damp sponge; a non-abrasive liquid cleanser can be used, applied to the sponge, not the tray. Dry it thoroughly before putting it back.
  3. Wipe the inside walls with a soft damp sponge. Breville’s oven walls have a nonstick coating; a non-abrasive liquid cleanser or mild spray solution can be used, applied to the sponge rather than the oven.
  4. Clean the heating elements gently, if needed. Breville’s quartz elements: “gently rub a soft, damp sponge or cloth along the length of the heating element. Do not use any type of cleanser or cleaning agent.”
  5. Wash the racks and pans in warm soapy water with a soft sponge. Breville warns abrasive cleansers, metal pads and utensils damage the enamel baking pan and broil rack and scratch the nonstick pizza pan.
  6. Clean the glass door with glass cleaner or a mild detergent on a soft damp sponge or soft plastic scouring pad, never an abrasive cleanser or metal pad.
  7. Let every surface dry before plugging the oven back in.

To keep the oven cleaner, line the baking pan (not the crumb tray or oven floor) with foil or parchment. See can you put aluminum foil in a toaster oven.

Stainless Steel and Painted Exteriors

Wipe with a damp cloth and dry. Breville suggests a soft damp sponge with a non-abrasive cleanser applied to the sponge for the oven body, and says abrasive cleansers and metal scouring pads will scratch the surface.

Toaster Cleaning FAQ

How do you clean the inside of a toaster?

You don’t reach inside. Unplug it, let it cool, empty the crumb tray and shake the toaster upside down over the trash. Never use a knife, fork or brush with metal bristles near the elements.

How often should you clean a toaster?

Empty the crumb tray weekly if you use the toaster daily, Hamilton Beach says. Toaster ovens: Breville says to clear the crumb tray after each use.

Can you wash a toaster crumb tray in the dishwasher?

None of the manuals we checked says so. Wipe it with a damp cloth, dry it and slide it back in.

Can you use oven cleaner on a toaster oven?

No. Breville’s manual says not to use abrasive cleansers on any interior or exterior surface, and its toaster manual specifically rules out oven cleaners.

How do I get burnt-on food off toaster oven racks?

Soak and wash the racks and pans in warm soapy water with a soft sponge or soft plastic pad. Breville says metal pads damage its enamel pans.

Why does my toaster smell like burning after cleaning?

Usually leftover crumbs or water. Make sure the crumb tray is back in, everything is dry, and shake out any remaining crumbs. With a new toaster, Breville suggests one cycle on the maximum setting without bread and says it “may emit a thin smoke or distinct odor on initial use,” which is normal. If a burning-plastic smell continues after that, stop using it.

Sources