The short answer: buy a pop-up toaster if you mostly make toast, bagels and frozen waffles; buy a toaster oven if you also want to bake, broil, reheat leftovers or air fry. A toaster is smaller, cheaper and uses less electricity per slice. A toaster oven does far more, takes about twice the counter space and draws 1,800 W for longer. Plenty of kitchens have both.

Side by Side

Pop-up toasterToaster oven
What it doesToast, bagels, frozen waffles and pastries, English muffinsToast, bake, broil, roast, reheat, pizza; many air fry, dehydrate or slow cook
Capacity2 or 4 slices4 slices (Breville Mini Smart Oven) to 9 slices (Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro); 11- to 13-inch pizza
Power850–1,100 W (2-slice), 1,400–1,800 W (4-slice)Mostly 1,800 W; 1,120–1,400 W on small Hamilton Beach models
Counter spaceAbout 11 × 7 in (2-slice) to 11 × 11 in (4-slice)About 15 × 12 in (Cuisinart TOA-70NAS) to 21.4 × 17.3 in (Breville BOV900), plus about 4 in of clearance around it
Bread shapeLimited by slot width (1 to 1.5 in) and lengthAnything that fits on the rack: thick slices, open-face sandwiches, toast with cheese
Price on Amazon (Nov 19, 2026)About $22 (Proctor Silex) to $450 (Revolution R180 Connect Plus)About $60 (Hamilton Beach Easy Reach) to $400 (Breville Joule Oven Air Fryer Pro)
Warranty1 to 3 years (Cuisinart 3-year limited)1 to 3 years (Breville BOV900 2 years, Cuisinart 3-year limited)

Speed and Energy

A pop-up toaster heats only two narrow slots right next to the bread. A toaster oven heats a whole cavity and its racks, so it takes longer to toast and draws its full 1,800 W for the whole time.

Energy per job, at 18.16¢/kWh (the August 2026 US average):

JobApplianceEnergyCost
2 slices, 3 minutes900 W pop-up toaster0.045 kWh0.8¢
4 slices, 3 minutes1,800 W 4-slice toaster0.09 kWh1.6¢
15 minutes (preheat + bake or toast)1,800 W toaster oven0.45 kWh8.2¢

For toast alone, the toaster wins. For a small bake or reheat, the toaster oven uses less energy than heating a full-size oven. More in how many watts a toaster uses.

What a Toaster Oven Does That a Toaster Can’t

  • Bake and roast small batches: cookies, a chicken breast, roasted vegetables. Larger ovens fit a 9 × 13 pan (Breville BOV900, Cuisinart TOA-95NAS, Black+Decker TO3250XSB).
  • Broil: melt cheese on toast, brown a gratin.
  • Reheat pizza and leftovers with a crisp crust, where a microwave turns them soft. See microwave vs. toaster oven.
  • Air fry on combo models such as the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro and Cuisinart TOA-70NAS.

What a Toaster Does Better

  • Speed and simplicity for everyday toast: drop the bread in, press the lever, and it pops up when done.
  • Bagels: most pop-ups have a bagel setting that toasts the cut side and only warms the crust.
  • Size: a 2-slice toaster takes about a third of the counter area of a mid-size toaster oven and doesn’t need clearance on every side. See toaster oven clearance.
  • Price: a 2-slice toaster from Hamilton Beach, Cuisinart or KitchenAid cost $30 to $48 on Amazon on November 19, 2026.

If you mostly make toast

Breville BTA720XL Bit More 2-Slice Toaster

2-slice toaster with A Bit More, Lift and Look, bagel and frozen buttons and a browning progress light. $109.95 on Amazon Nov 19.

If you want to bake and air fry

Breville BOV900BSS Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro

1,800 W, 1 cu ft oven: toasts 9 slices, fits most 9x13 pans, 13 functions including air fry and dehydrate.

Which Should You Buy?

  • Toast, bagels and waffles most mornings, limited counter: a pop-up toaster.
  • You cook small meals and don’t want to heat the big oven: a toaster oven, ideally one with convection or air fry.
  • A household that toasts a lot and cooks small meals: both. A 2-slice toaster plus a toaster oven covers more than a large combo oven alone.
  • Dorm or studio with one appliance: a small toaster oven, since it also reheats and bakes (check dorm rules on heating appliances).

Toaster vs. Toaster Oven FAQ

Is a toaster oven better than a toaster for toast?

A pop-up toaster is faster and toasts both sides at once. A toaster oven handles thick or open-face bread and toast with toppings, but it takes longer and uses more energy per slice.

Does a toaster oven use more electricity than a toaster?

Per job, yes: most toaster ovens draw 1,800 W and run longer. Fifteen minutes uses about 0.45 kWh (8 cents), against about 0.045 kWh (under 1 cent) for a 900 W toaster’s 3-minute cycle.

Can a toaster oven replace a toaster?

Yes, if you don’t mind slower toast. Every toaster oven has a toast function; Breville’s Smart Ovens toast 4 to 9 slices depending on the model.

Can a toaster replace a toaster oven?

No. A pop-up toaster can’t bake, broil or reheat anything that doesn’t fit in a slot. Toaster bags let it warm sandwiches, see are toaster bags safe.

Which is safer, a toaster or a toaster oven?

Both are heating appliances that need clearance and crumb cleaning. Toaster ovens have hot glass doors and outer surfaces, and French-door countertop ovens from Oster (2025) and Gourmia (2026) have been recalled because their doors can close unexpectedly. See toaster and toaster oven recalls.

Sources