The short answer: buy a toaster oven if you want toast, pizza and small bakes, a basket air fryer if you mostly crisp frozen food and reheat, and an air fryer toaster oven if you want both and have the counter space. A basket air fryer can’t make toast or hold a flat pan; a plain toaster oven doesn’t crisp fries the way a basket does. Air fryer toaster ovens (Breville BOV860 and BOV900, Ninja SP151 and FO101, Cuisinart TOA-70NAS) add an air fry setting and a mesh basket to a toaster oven.

Toaster Oven vs. Air Fryer at a Glance

Toaster ovenBasket air fryerAir fryer toaster oven
Toast and bagelsYes, 4–9 slicesNoYes
Pizza9–13 inNo (round baskets)12–13 in
Baking pansUp to 9x13 in the largest ovensSmall cake pans onlyUp to 9x13 in the largest (Breville BOV900)
Crisping frozen fries, wingsConvection only, no basketMain job; shake the basketYes, with a mesh basket
Capacity0.45–1 cu ft4–6 qt baskets (8 qt in dual-basket models)0.6–1 cu ft
Typical power1,300–1,800 W1,300–1,800 W1,800 W
Counter space13–21 in wideSmaller footprint, taller15–21 in wide
CleaningCrumb tray, racks, pansBasket and crisper plateCrumb tray, racks, basket

When a Basket Air Fryer Is Better

  • Frozen food and leftovers. A deep basket you can shake is the simplest way to crisp fries, nuggets and wings.
  • Small counters. A 4- to 6-quart basket takes less width than a 6-slice oven.
  • Price. Single-basket fryers generally cost less than air fryer ovens of the same brand.

When a Toaster Oven Is Better

  • Toast, bagels and English muffins. A basket air fryer can’t do these well in quantity.
  • Flat foods. Pizza, sheet-pan vegetables, cookies, open-face sandwiches.
  • Baking. Muffins, a small casserole, and in the largest ovens a 9x13 pan.
  • Watching food. Glass doors let you see browning without stopping the cook.

When to Buy an Air Fryer Toaster Oven

If you’d otherwise buy both, one oven saves counter space. The trade-off is that an oven-style air fryer has a shallower layer of food on a wide basket, so you get more surface area but you can’t shake it like a drawer.

Which Should You Buy?

  • Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV860), $279.95: 6-slice toaster oven with air fry, 13-inch pizza.
  • Ninja Flip SP151, $149.95: air fries and toasts 6 slices, then flips up against the backsplash.
  • A basket air fryer if you already own a toaster oven: see the best air fryers.

Toaster oven and air fryer in one

Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer BOV860BSS

6-slice convection oven with 11 functions including air fry and a 13-inch pizza pan.

Cheaper two-in-one

Ninja Flip Toaster Oven & Air Fryer SP151

8-function, 1,800 W oven that air fries, fits 6 slices or a 12-inch pizza, and flips up for storage.

Prices checked November 19, 2026, on Amazon (sold by Amazon for the Ninja; Sur La Table for the Breville BOV860BSS).

More: the best air fryer toaster ovens, the best toaster ovens, and microwave vs. toaster oven.

Toaster Oven vs. Air Fryer FAQ

Can an air fryer replace a toaster oven?

For frozen food and reheating, mostly. It can’t toast several slices at once or hold a pizza or a 9x13 pan. An air fryer toaster oven can replace both.

Can a toaster oven replace an air fryer?

A toaster oven with an Air Fry setting and a mesh basket can. A plain convection toaster oven crisps food, but Breville’s Smart Oven Pro, for example, has no air fry mode.

Which uses more electricity, a toaster oven or an air fryer?

Both are usually 1,300–1,800 W appliances, so the cost per hour is similar; the shorter cook time wins. See toaster oven energy use.

Is an air fryer toaster oven worth it?

If you’d use both an air fryer and a toaster oven, yes: it saves a second appliance and counter spot. If you only air fry, a basket fryer is smaller and cheaper.

Sources