The short answer: buy the Moccamaster KBGV Select if you want the simplest, longest-lasting brewer, and the Breville Luxe Brewer if you want to adjust temperature, bloom and flow. Breville has discontinued the Precision Brewer: its thermal, glass and Brewer’s Cup versions are all marked discontinued on breville.com. Its replacement, the Luxe Brewer Glass (BDC415), is $319.95 and keeps the adjustable brewing. The Moccamaster KBGV Select is $369, has two switches, is handmade in the Netherlands and carries a five-year warranty. Both the Luxe Brewer and the Moccamaster are on the Specialty Coffee Association’s current certified list; the Precision Brewer isn’t.

Precision Brewer vs. Luxe Brewer vs. Moccamaster

Breville Precision BrewerBreville Luxe Brewer GlassMoccamaster KBGV Select
ModelBDC450 (thermal), BDC400 (glass)BDC41553941 and other colors
StatusDiscontinuedCurrentCurrent
Price, Nov. 16, 2026BDC400 $299.95 on Amazon (remaining stock)$319.95 (Breville and Amazon)$369 (Moccamaster)
Capacity60 oz, 12 cups60 oz, 12 cups40 oz, 10 cups
CarafeThermal (BDC450) or glass (BDC400)Glass on a warming plate; thermal version is BDC465Glass on a hot plate; thermal version is the KBT
Brew settingsGold, Fast, Strong, Iced, Cold Brew, My BrewOne Touch, Cold Brew, Custom Brew (bloom volume and time, temperature, flow rate)None: on/off, plus a full or half carafe selector
Brew temperatureAdjustable (My Brew)Adjustable (Custom Brew)Fixed, 196 to 205°F
Delay startYesYes, up to 24 hoursNo
SCA Certified Home BrewerNot on the current listYes (2025)Yes (2026)
Where madeNot stated per modelNot stated per modelHandmade in the Netherlands
Warranty2-year repair or replacement2-year repair or replacement5 years, plus repair for life

Specs are from breville.com, us.moccamaster.com and the SCA’s certified home brewer list, checked November 16, 2026.

The Precision Brewer Is Discontinued

Breville’s US pages for the Precision Brewer Thermal (BDC450), Precision Brewer Glass (BDC400) and Precision Brewer Brewer’s Cup (BDC455) all say the model has been discontinued. Amazon was still selling the glass BDC400 at $299.95 on November 16, but once remaining stock is gone, the Luxe Brewer is Breville’s drip brewer.

If you own a Precision Brewer, nothing changes: Breville’s warranty still applies for the rest of its two-year term, and Breville’s support pages keep the manuals.

Luxe Brewer vs. Moccamaster: Which Makes Better Coffee?

Both meet the SCA’s brewing standards, which require the right water temperature, brew time and extraction for a full batch. The difference is control.

The Moccamaster does one thing: it heats water with a copper element to 196 to 205°F and brews a full 40 oz pot in about four to six minutes. There’s no clock, no program and no temperature setting. A selector switch chooses a full or half carafe and adjusts the brew for that volume, and the basket stops dripping when you pull the carafe out. That’s the whole interface, and it’s why Moccamasters run for years: there’s little to fail, Moccamaster sells replacement parts, and every brewer has a five-year warranty and lifetime repair.

The Luxe Brewer brews a larger 60 oz batch and lets you change bloom volume, bloom time, brew temperature and flow rate, then remembers your settings. It adds cold brew and a 24-hour delay start, so the coffee can be ready when you wake up, which the Moccamaster can’t do.

Pick the Moccamaster for durability and simplicity, the Luxe Brewer for programming and tuning. If you want a timer and a thermal carafe for less, the OXO 8-Cup vs. Moccamaster comparison covers the OXO, which is also SCA certified, and Moccamaster vs. Fellow Aiden covers the app-controlled alternative.

Best for simplicity and longevity

Moccamaster KBGV Select

Handmade in the Netherlands, SCA certified, brews 40 oz at 196 to 205°F in about 4 to 6 minutes. Five-year warranty.

Best for adjustable brewing

Breville Luxe Brewer Glass

The Precision Brewer's replacement: 60 oz, SCA certified, adjustable bloom, temperature and flow, plus cold brew.

Discontinued; remaining stock

Breville Precision Brewer Glass

The original 60 oz Precision Brewer with Gold, Fast, Strong, Iced, Cold Brew and My Brew modes.

For more drip picks, see the best coffee makers and the full SCA certified coffee makers list.

Breville Precision Brewer vs. Moccamaster FAQ

Is the Breville Precision Brewer discontinued?

Yes. Breville’s US site lists the Precision Brewer Thermal (BDC450), Glass (BDC400) and Brewer’s Cup (BDC455) as discontinued. Its replacement is the Luxe Brewer, $319.95 for the glass-carafe BDC415.

Is the Moccamaster better than the Breville Precision Brewer?

For simplicity and longevity, yes: it’s handmade in the Netherlands, has a five-year warranty and is on the SCA’s current certified list. The Precision Brewer, and now the Luxe Brewer, are better if you want to adjust brew temperature, bloom and flow, or schedule a pot with a timer.

Is the Moccamaster worth the money?

It’s worth it if you brew a pot most days and want a machine that lasts. At $369 it costs $49 more than the Luxe Brewer, but its warranty is five years instead of two, and Moccamaster repairs its brewers for life.

Is the Breville Precision Brewer worth it in 2026?

Only at a clear discount, since it’s discontinued. The Luxe Brewer costs $319.95, keeps the adjustable brewing and is SCA certified.

What replaced the Breville Precision Brewer?

The Breville Luxe Brewer: the glass-carafe BDC415 ($319.95) and the thermal-carafe BDC465. Both were added to the SCA’s certified home brewer list in 2025.

Which Moccamaster is the KBGV Select?

The KBGV Select is Moccamaster’s 40 oz glass-carafe brewer with a full or half carafe selector switch and an automatic drip-stop. The KBT is the same brewer with a thermal carafe.