The short answer: buy a Bissell, rent a Rug Doctor. For a machine you own, Bissell is better at every price: a $94.99 Little Green, a $99.99 TurboClean, $200 to $300 Revolutions and the $429 Big Green with a 5-year warranty. Rug Doctor’s cheapest upright for sale is the TruDeep at $499.99, its Mighty Pro X3 lists at $597.99, and all of them carry a 1-year warranty. Where Rug Doctor wins is renting: $39.99 for 24 hours at its rental locations, which now rent Bissell Big Green machines too, at the same price. Prices are from rugdoctor.com, bissell.com and Amazon on November 21, 2026.

The two brands are now closely tied. Rug Doctor’s site says “Rug Doctor + BISSELL Rental join forces,” its pages are titled “Rug Doctor by BISSELL,” and its formulas on Amazon are labeled “Rug Doctor by BISSELL.”

Bissell vs. Rug Doctor: Machines You Can Buy

TypeBissellRug Doctor
Portable spot cleanerLittle Green 1400B, $94.99 (1-year, listing); SpotClean Pet Pro 2458, $185.52 (2-year, listing)Pet Portable Spot Cleaner, $189.99 rugdoctor.com / $162.99 Amazon (1-year, listing)
Compact uprightTurboClean 3952, $99.99None
Mid-size uprightRevolution ExpressClean $199.99; ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus $237.97; Revolution HydroSteam $249.99None
Large uprightBig Green 86T3, $429.00, 1.75 gal, 9 ft hose included, 5-year warrantyTruDeep 90115 $499.99; Mighty Pro X3 90010 $597.99 (3-gal solution tank, upholstery tool extra); Pro Deep 90028 $649.99 (two 1.5-gal tanks)
Warranty1 to 5 years by model1 year, consumer and commercial (manual)

Renting

Rug Doctor uprightBissell Big GreenLittle Green Pro
24 hours$39.99$39.99$29.99
48 hours$49.99$49.99$39.99
Upholstery tool+$5.99+$5.99—
WhereRug Doctor rental locations (over 35,000, per Rug Doctor)Rug Doctor locationsRug Doctor locations

A $40 refundable deposit may be required, and Rug Doctor charges $40 for a dirty or late return. The 48-hour rate must be chosen at pickup and isn’t offered everywhere. Formula is extra. See Rug Doctor rental cost and Bissell Big Green rental cost.

Where Bissell Wins

  • Price to own. A Big Green costs $70 less than Rug Doctor’s cheapest upright and $169 less than a Mighty Pro X3 at rugdoctor.com prices.
  • Warranty. The Big Green’s manual gives 5 years. Rug Doctor’s Mighty Pro X3 manual gives 1 year.
  • Range. Bissell sells compact, heated and portable machines from under $100. Rug Doctor sells one portable and three large uprights.
  • Tools included. The Big Green comes with a 9 ft hose and 6-inch stain tool. The X3’s upholstery tool was $91.19 extra on Amazon.

Where Rug Doctor Wins

  • Renting. The biggest rental network, and the cheapest way to clean carpet once a year.
  • Tank size. The Mighty Pro X3’s manual gives a 3-gallon solution tank, against 1.75 gallons on the Big Green.
  • Commercial use. Rug Doctor’s 1-year warranty covers consumer and commercial use. Bissell’s home machines void their warranty if used commercially.

Rules Both Brands Set

  • Formula. Bissell’s manuals say non-Bissell cleaning solutions “will void the warranty.” Rug Doctor’s manual says to use only Rug Doctor cleaning products intended for the machine.
  • Water. Bissell allows hot tap water up to 140°F, never boiling. Rug Doctor’s manual says to mix its formula into hot tap water, but not so hot it could scald.
  • Wool and natural fibers. Rug Doctor’s manual says not to use its machines on wool, silk, natural-fiber, sisal, jute, hand-loomed or braided rugs. Bissell says to check the rug’s tag and test first, and not to deep-clean wool or antique rugs without a maker’s tag.

Which Should You Buy?

  • Clean once a year: rent a Rug Doctor or a Big Green for $39.99.
  • Clean several times a year: buy the Bissell Big Green, or a Revolution if you want something lighter.
  • Clean a lot of carpet, or for a small business: the Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3’s bigger tank and commercial warranty make sense.
  • Spot cleaning: the Bissell Little Green at about half the price of the Rug Doctor portable.

Best to own

Bissell Big Green Machine Professional 86T3

1.75-gallon tank, 8-row brush, 9 ft hose and 6-inch stain tool, 25 ft cord and a 5-year warranty.

For big jobs

Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 with Oxy Pack

The Rug Doctor you rent, to own: 3-gallon solution tank, vibrating brush, 1-year warranty.

Best spot cleaner

Bissell Little Green 1400B

48 oz clean tank, spray-scrub-suction stain tool and 95,239 Amazon ratings for $94.99.

Rug Doctor's portable

Rug Doctor Pet Portable Spot Cleaner

Portable with a dual-action pet tool, wheels and a retractable handle, 1-year warranty.

See also Bissell Big Green vs. Rug Doctor, Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 vs. Bissell Big Green, is Rug Doctor worth buying and is it cheaper to buy or rent a carpet cleaner.

Bissell vs. Rug Doctor FAQ

Is Bissell or Rug Doctor better for home use?

To buy, Bissell: its machines cost less, include tools and carry warranties up to 5 years (Big Green). To rent, Rug Doctor: $39.99 for 24 hours, and its locations rent Big Green machines too.

Does Bissell own Rug Doctor?

Rug Doctor’s site says “Rug Doctor + BISSELL Rental join forces,” titles its pages “Rug Doctor by BISSELL,” and its formulas are sold as “Rug Doctor by BISSELL.” Neither company’s pages we read on November 21, 2026 spelled out the ownership terms.

Can you rent a Bissell Big Green?

Yes, at Rug Doctor rental locations: $39.99 for 24 hours or $49.99 for 48 hours, plus $5.99 for the upholstery tool.

Can you use Bissell formula in a Rug Doctor?

Rug Doctor’s manual says to use only Rug Doctor cleaning products intended for the machine, and Bissell says the same about its own machines. Use each maker’s formula in its machine.

Can you use a Rug Doctor on a wool rug?

No. Rug Doctor’s manual says not to use its machines or cleaning products on wool, silk, natural-fiber, hand-loomed, braided, sisal or jute rugs.

Sources