If you clean your carpets more than once or twice a year, buying is cheaper within a few years. If you clean once a year or less, renting wins. A Rug Doctor or Big Green rental costs $39.99 for 24 hours or $49.99 for 48 hours, plus formula. A Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus costs $237.97 on Amazon (November 21, 2026), the price of about six one-day rentals. A Bissell Big Green costs $429.00, about 11 rentals.

Owning has other advantages: you can clean a pet accident the same day, and you don’t have to haul a 40-pound machine to and from a store. Renting gets you a bigger, pro-style machine with no storage and no upkeep.

Rental Prices (Rug Doctor Locations, November 2026)

Rental24 hours48 hours
Rug Doctor upright (Pro Deep, Mighty Pro, Wide Track)$39.99$49.99
Bissell Big Green rental$39.99$49.99
Little Green Pro (portable)$29.99$39.99
Upholstery tool add-on$5.99$5.99

Other costs:

  • Deposit: a refundable $40 “may be required,” depending on the location.
  • Fees: $40 if the machine comes back dirty, and a $40 late fee.
  • 48-hour option: you have to choose it at checkout, and not every location offers it.
  • Formula: sold separately. Rug Doctor Oxy Deep is $19.54 for 80 ounces on Amazon if you buy it ahead.

Rug Doctor says the Rug Doctor and Bissell rental fleets “join forces,” and Big Green rental machines are rented through Rug Doctor locations. Prices “may vary by location.” See Rug Doctor rental cost, Bissell Big Green rental cost and where to rent a carpet cleaner.

Break-Even: How Many Rentals Does a Machine Cost?

Formula costs about the same either way, so the comparison is machine price vs. the $39.99 one-day rental fee.

MachineAmazon price, Nov. 21, 2026Equal to this many 24-hour rentalsCleaning twice a year, pays off in
Bissell TurboClean 3952$99.992.5About 1.3 years
Hoover PowerDash Pet$109.992.8About 1.4 years
Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus 3588F$237.976About 3 years
Bissell Big Green 86T3$429.0010.7About 5.4 years
Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 (Pet pack)$534.1013.4About 6.7 years

If you clean four times a year, the Big Green pays off in under three years. If you clean once a year, a ProHeat takes six years and a Big Green more than ten.

Warranties matter here too. Bissell gives the Big Green a 5-year limited warranty, about its payback time at two cleans a year. Rug Doctor’s Mighty Pro X3 has a 1-year warranty.

Rent If…

Buy If…

  • You have pets or kids and clean spots every week. A $95 Bissell Little Green pays for itself after about three portable rentals.
  • You clean whole rooms two or more times a year.
  • You want to clean the moment something spills, without a trip to the store.

Compared With Hiring a Pro

Professional hot water extraction typically costs about $0.20 to $0.50 per square foot, or roughly $120 to $250 for a typical job. Some carpet warranties, such as Mohawk’s, require a professional cleaning every 18 months with a receipt, whatever you do at home. See professional carpet cleaning cost and does a home carpet cleaner void your carpet warranty.

Machines Worth Buying

Pays off in about 6 rentals

Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus (3588F)

11-inch path, 1-gallon tank, 8-foot hose with pet tools, 17.5 lb.

The ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus 3588F ($237.97, list $279.99) is the best value if you clean twice a year or more.

The rental-style machine to own

Bissell Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner (86T3)

Bissell's largest home machine: 1.75-gallon clean tank, 9-foot hose and a 5-year limited warranty.

The Bissell Big Green 86T3 ($429.00, not discounted for Black Friday) is the one to own if you clean often and want rental-style capacity. See is the Bissell Big Green the same as the rental? and our Big Green review.

Cheaper than three portable rentals

Bissell Little Green Portable Carpet Cleaner (1400B)

Bissell's best-selling spot cleaner with a 48 oz tank and 4.5-foot hose.

The Bissell Little Green 1400B ($94.99) costs about what three Little Green Pro day rentals do.

Buy vs. Rent FAQ

How much does it cost to rent a carpet cleaner?

At Rug Doctor locations, $39.99 for 24 hours or $49.99 for 48 hours for an upright, $29.99 for a day with the Little Green Pro, plus formula and a $5.99 upholstery tool if you want one.

Is a rental machine better than one you buy?

Rentals are pro-style machines with big tanks. The Mighty Pro X3 for sale holds 3 gallons. But a home Big Green is close, and you can use it whenever you want.

Do I need to buy formula when renting?

Yes. Rental formula is sold separately, and Rug Doctor says to use only Rug Doctor cleaners in its machines.

What happens if I return a rental dirty or late?

Rug Doctor charges $40 for a machine returned dirty and $40 for a late return.

Sources