The short answer: at the same price, the Brondell Swash 1400 gives you more for the money, and a TOTO Washlet S5 is the pick if bowl cleaning and a slimmer seat matter more than features per dollar. Both brands now sell instant-heat seats with endless warm water, so the old “TOTO tank vs. Brondell tankless” split only applies to TOTO’s outgoing C2 and C5. The Swash 1400 adds two stainless steel nozzles, seven nozzle positions, a nightlight and a 3-year tiered warranty for $479.99 on sale. The Washlet S5 adds PREMIST (it mists the bowl before you sit), EWATER+ wand cleaning and four user presets, with a 1-year warranty.

Prices on November 18, 2026: Brondell Swash 1400 $479.99–$495.99 on brondell.com (was $599.99), $549.99 on Amazon. TOTO Washlet S5 elongated $548.89 on Amazon (third-party seller), round $682 (sold by Amazon.com); TOTO’s list price is $974. Washlet S2 elongated $368.99 on Amazon. Washlet C5 elongated $467.65 (sold by Amazon.com).

TOTO Washlet vs. Brondell Swash at a Glance

TOTO Washlet S5TOTO Washlet S2TOTO Washlet C5 (outgoing)Brondell Swash 1400
Model numbersSW3446 (elongated), SW3445 (round)SW3346, SW3345SW3084 (elongated), SW3083 (round)S1400-EW, S1400-RW
Water heatingInstantInstantTankInstant (ceramic)
Rated power1,271 W (max 1,426 W)1,273 W (max 1,428 W)403 W (max 512 W)1,200 W
ControlsWall remote, 4 user presetsSide arm panelSlim wall remoteRemote, 2 user presets
NozzleOne retractable wandOne retractable wandOne retractable wandTwo stainless steel nozzles, 7 positions
Bowl and wand cleaningPREMIST, EWATER+PREMIST, EWATER+PREMIST, EWATER+ on the wandNozzle self-rinse
DryerYes, 3 temperaturesYes, 3 temperaturesYesYes, 4 levels
Nightlight / deodorizerYes / YesYes / YesDeodorizerYes / carbon filter
Seat weight limitNot on the spec sheetNot on the spec sheetNot on the spec sheet330 lb
Warranty1 year1 year1 year3-year tiered
Price (Nov 18, 2026)$548.89 Amazon (E)$368.99 Amazon (E)$467.65 Amazon (E)$479.99 brondell.com

Which TOTO Washlet Should You Compare?

TOTO’s current retrofit Washlets are the S2, S5, KS5, KS6, S7 and S7A, and all six heat water instantly. TOTO’s own pages mark the C2 and C5 as “limited inventory”: they are the last tank models, rated at 403 W, and the S2 replaces the C2. If a comparison you read says “TOTO runs out of warm water and Brondell doesn’t,” it is comparing the C5 with a Swash 1400. Against an S2 or S5, both brands give continuous warm water.

The fair pairings on price are:

  • Washlet S2 vs. Swash 1400: both around $370–$480, both instant heat. The S2 has a side arm panel instead of a remote.
  • Washlet S5 vs. Swash 1400: the S5 adds a remote and four user presets and costs about $70 more on Amazon.
  • Washlet S7 vs. Brondell’s Thinline T44: TOTO’s S7 adds EWATER+ to the bowl and a 2-year warranty, but it costs $999.99 and up.

For every Washlet side by side, see TOTO Washlet models compared.

Brondell Swash 1400 vs. TOTO Washlet C5

This was the most-asked version of the question, because the C5 was TOTO’s best seller for years. The Swash 1400 is the better seat today:

  • Warm water: the C5 keeps a heated tank (403 W). The Swash 1400 heats water on demand (1,200 W), so a long wash stays warm.
  • Nozzles: the C5 uses one wand for both front and rear washing. The Swash 1400 has separate stainless steel nozzles, seven positions and adjustable spray width.
  • Extras: the Swash 1400 has a nightlight, two user presets and an auto mode. The C5 has PREMIST and EWATER+ on the wand, which the Swash doesn’t.
  • Warranty: 1 year on the C5 against a 3-year tiered warranty on the Swash 1400 (100% of parts and labor in year 1, 75% in year 2, 50% in year 3).
  • Price: about $468 for the C5 and $479.99 for the Swash 1400 on sale.

Buy the C5 only if you want TOTO’s bowl-misting and wand-cleaning system at the lowest TOTO price while stock lasts. Otherwise the Washlet S5 is the C5’s real replacement. For that upgrade on its own, see TOTO Washlet C5 vs. S7.

Where TOTO Is Better

  • Bowl hygiene. PREMIST wets the bowl before use so waste sticks less, and EWATER+ sprays electrolyzed water over the wand after each use. Brondell’s Swash seats self-rinse the nozzles but don’t claim electrolyzed water or UV.
  • Seat design. The S5 is low and smooth, with no exposed hoses on compatible TOTO toilets.
  • Four user presets on the S5 against two on the Swash 1400.

Where Brondell Is Better

  • Value. For the same money you get two nozzles, a nightlight and a remote. A TOTO with a remote starts with the S5.
  • Warranty. The Swash 1000, 1400, Thinline seats and CL2200 carry a 3-year tiered warranty. TOTO gives 1 year on everything except the S7 and S7A (2 years).
  • A published weight limit. Brondell rates the Swash 1400 seat for 330 lb.

Which Should You Buy?

Best value

Brondell Swash 1400

Instant warm water, two stainless steel nozzles with seven positions, nightlight, 2 user presets and a 3-year tiered warranty.

Best TOTO for most people

TOTO Washlet S5 (Elongated)

Instant warm water, PREMIST bowl mist, EWATER+ wand cleaning, remote with 4 user presets. SW3446.

Cheapest current TOTO

TOTO Washlet S2 (Elongated)

The S5's instant heater, PREMIST and EWATER+ with a side arm panel instead of a remote. SW3346.

Two buying notes:

  • TOTO’s warranty requires an authorized US seller. Several TOTO listings on Amazon come from third-party sellers, so check the seller before you order. The C5, KS5, KS6 and S5 round are sold by Amazon.com itself.
  • Brondell takes back only unopened seats, within 30 days, with a 10% restocking fee. Measure your toilet before ordering. Brondell’s fit rule is 18–19.5 in from the bolt holes to the front of the bowl for elongated, 16.5–17.75 in for round.

If your budget is under $300, see the best bidet seats under $300. All our picks are in the best bidet toilet seats.

TOTO Washlet vs. Brondell Swash FAQ

Is TOTO better than Brondell?

TOTO is better at bowl and wand hygiene (PREMIST and EWATER+) and has the slimmer seat design. Brondell gives more features and a longer warranty for the money. At $480–$550, the Swash 1400 has more features than any TOTO Washlet at that price.

Is the Brondell Swash 1400 better than the TOTO Washlet C5?

For most buyers, yes. It heats water on demand instead of from a tank, has two stainless steel nozzles, a nightlight and a 3-year tiered warranty, and costs about the same as the C5. The C5 has PREMIST and EWATER+ wand cleaning, which the Swash lacks.

Is the TOTO Washlet C5 discontinued?

TOTO’s US site lists the C5 (SW3084) and C2 as “limited inventory”. The instant-heat S5 and S2 replace them. Amazon.com still sold the C5 elongated for $467.65 on November 18, 2026.

Do TOTO Washlets have endless warm water?

The current S2, S5, KS5, KS6, S7 and S7A heat water instantly, so yes. The outgoing C2 and C5 use a heated tank.

What warranty do TOTO and Brondell give?

TOTO gives 1 year on Washlets and 2 years on the S7 and S7A, for the original buyer from an authorized seller. Brondell gives a 3-year tiered warranty on the Swash 1000, 1400, Thinline seats and CL2200, and 1 year on its other seats. See bidet warranties for every brand.

Do both need a GFCI outlet?

Yes. TOTO voids the warranty without a 120 V GFCI outlet and the factory cord. Brondell’s manuals call for a grounded GFCI outlet. The Swash 1400’s cord is 3.5 ft and the S5’s is 3.9 ft.

Sources