The short answer: Hamilton Beach for the lowest price, Cuisinart for the warranty and published specs. Hamilton Beach’s 2-slice toasters start under $30 and its Sure-Toast models are built for single slices. Cuisinart costs a little more but gives a limited 3-year warranty. Hamilton Beach gives 1 year in the US, and its manual makes you pay shipping both ways for a warranty claim.

Prices below were checked on Amazon on November 19, 2026, except where noted.

Side by Side

Hamilton Beach 22633Cuisinart CPT-122Hamilton Beach 22996Cuisinart CPT-180P1
Slices2224
Slots“Extra-wide” (no width published)1.5 inExtra-wide, 6.5 in long1.5 in
Shades7776 per pair
ExtrasBagel (cut side only), defrost, Toast Boost, auto shutoffReheat, defrost, bagelSure-Toast single-slice, bagel, Toast BoostTwo independent dials, reheat, defrost, bagel
Power850 W900 WNot published1800 W
Warranty (US)1 year, owner pays shipping both waysLimited 3-year1 yearLimited 3-year
Amazon (Nov 19)$29.95$37.49$44.95$52.49

Hamilton Beach doesn’t publish wattage on its toaster pages; the 850 W figure for the 22633G is from restaurant supplier Webstaurant. Toast Boost is Hamilton Beach’s name for a lever that lifts small items higher.

Model Numbers

Hamilton Beach adds letter suffixes for revisions and store channels. The 22633G replaced the 22633, and hamiltonbeach.com showed the 22633G out of stock on November 19 while Amazon sold the 22633 and 22634. hamiltonbeach.com also lists “Recertified” units with an R prefix; those aren’t new toasters.

Cuisinart moved most toasters to a P1 suffix (CPT-180P1, CPT-142P1). The CPT-122 kept its number.

Which Should You Buy?

  • Buy Hamilton Beach if price comes first. The 22633 ($29.95) does the basics with a defrost and bagel setting, and the 22996 Sure-Toast ($44.95) suits households that often toast one slice.
  • Buy Cuisinart if you want the longer warranty and published slot widths. The CPT-122 ($37.49) is $7.54 more than the 22633 and adds two years of coverage.

Best for the warranty

Cuisinart CPT-122 2-Slice Compact Toaster

900 W 2-slice toaster with 1.5-inch slots, a 7-setting dial, reheat, defrost and bagel, and a 3-year limited warranty.

Best for the price

Hamilton Beach 22633 Extra-Wide Slot 2-Slice Toaster

Extra-wide 2-slice with 7 shades, a cut-side-only bagel setting, defrost, Toast Boost lift and auto shutoff.

Best for single slices

Hamilton Beach 22996 Gourmet 2-Slice Sure-Toast Toaster

2-slice with Sure-Toast single-slice technology, 6.5-inch-long extra-wide slots, 7 shades, bagel and Toast Boost.

Hamilton Beach vs. Cuisinart FAQ

What is Hamilton Beach’s toaster warranty?

One year in the US (five years in Canada), per the 22633 manual. Hamilton Beach repairs or replaces the toaster, but you pay to ship it to them and to have it shipped back.

What is Cuisinart’s toaster warranty?

A limited 3-year warranty on retail toasters. Hotel versions with a “WH” suffix get 1 year.

What is Hamilton Beach Sure-Toast?

Sure-Toast is Hamilton Beach’s technology for toasting a single slice evenly, used on models such as the 22996 Gourmet 2-slice and the 24782 4-slice.

Which is cheaper, Hamilton Beach or Cuisinart?

Hamilton Beach. Its 2-slice toasters started at $27.95 to $29.95 on Amazon on November 19, against $37.49 for Cuisinart’s cheapest 2-slice.

Sources