The short answer: Breville for thick bread and a lower price, Revolution for presets and a touchscreen. The Breville Die-Cast (BTA820, $199.95) lowers and raises the bread with a motor, uses a classic 12-step browning slide and has extra-wide slots. Revolution’s R180 Connect Plus ($449.95, $359.95 on sale) replaces the dial with a touchscreen of 40+ foods, but its slots take food only up to 1 inch thick. Revolution’s warranty is longer: 2 years vs. Breville’s 1.

Side by Side

Breville Die-Cast 2-Slice (BTA820)Revolution R180 Connect Plus
Price, Nov 19$199.95$449.95 list; $359.95 on Amazon and in Revolution’s Nov 20–30 sale
ControlsButtons and a browning slideTouchscreen
Browning12 settings (‘1’ to ‘5’)7 shades per food
PresetsBagel, Frozen40+ food types incl. gluten-free; fresh, frozen, reheat
LoweringMotorized (“One Touch Auto Lowering”)n/s in the Connect Plus manual (the original R180 and the R270 have an automatic lift)
Extra timeA Bit More buttonn/s
Check mid-cycleLift & Look buttonn/s
Slots2 “extra-wide”2, about 1 in wide x 5.25 in long
Max thicknessn/s1 inch
Wi-FiNoYes: updates, clock, weather, photo frame
BodyDie-cast aluminumn/s
Power900 WAbout 1,500 W (maker listing)
Warranty1-year limited2-year limited (replacement)

Where Each Wins

Breville Die-Cast:

  • Half the price of a full-price Connect Plus, with motorized lowering.
  • Wider slots for sourdough and bakery bagels.
  • A Bit More and Lift & Look buttons for quick adjustments without guessing a preset.

Revolution:

  • Food-specific presets: pick waffle, pastry or gluten-free bread and the toaster sets the time.
  • Wi-Fi software updates and a photo-frame idle screen.
  • A 2-year warranty (current models, bought from Revolution or authorized sellers).

Cleaning and Care

Revolution’s manual says to clean only with a cloth dampened with water and not to spray the toaster with any cleaner. Breville’s toasters have a front slide-out crumb tray; Breville’s manual warns that an uncleaned crumb tray is a fire hazard. Both say to empty crumbs regularly.

Which Should You Buy?

  • Breville Die-Cast BTA820 if you toast thick bread, want the motor, or want to spend less. For four slots with two controls, the BTA840 ($249.95).
  • Revolution R180 Connect Plus if your household toasts many kinds of food and likes a one-tap preset per food. Buy it during the November 20–30 sale.
  • Revolution R90 Digital ($299.95) for Revolution’s touchscreen at a lower price, with 5 food types.

Best value motorized

Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster

Die-cast 2-slice toaster that lowers and raises the bread with a motor. 900 W, 12 browning settings. $199.95.

Best presets

Revolution R180 Connect Plus Smart Toaster

Touchscreen toaster with 40+ bread types, 7 shades, Wi-Fi and photo frame. $359.95 from Revolution.

More on each: is the Breville Die-Cast toaster worth it? and is the Revolution toaster worth it?

Breville vs. Revolution FAQ

Is Breville or Revolution the better toaster?

Breville’s Die-Cast is the better value and takes thicker bread. Revolution is better if you want touchscreen presets for many foods and a 2-year warranty.

Do both toasters lower the bread automatically?

Breville’s Die-Cast models have motorized “One Touch Auto Lowering”. Revolution’s original R180 and R270 manuals describe an automatic lift; the Connect Plus quick-start manual doesn’t mention one.

Which has wider slots, Breville or Revolution?

Breville. Revolution’s slots are about 1 inch wide and it says not to toast food thicker than one inch.

What warranty do Breville and Revolution give?

Breville: 1-year limited. Revolution: 2-year limited on current models bought from Revolution or an authorized seller.

Is the Revolution R270 better than the Breville Die-Cast?

The R270 is no longer on Revolution’s store. It added a customizable food library and accessory modes to the R180, but kept the 1-inch slot limit and carried a 1-year warranty in its manual.

Sources