The short answer: Breville for features, Cuisinart for value and warranty. Breville’s toasters add things Cuisinart’s don’t have: an “A Bit More” button, Lift & Look on every model, a long-slot 4-slice, and a die-cast motorized toaster. Cuisinart’s cost roughly half as much at each size and carry a 3-year limited warranty against Breville’s 1 year.

Prices below were checked on Amazon on November 19, 2026. Breville’s own Black Friday sale doesn’t include any of its pop-up toasters.

Model by Model

CategoryBrevilleCuisinart
Basic 2-sliceBTA720XL “A Bit More”: $109.95; Bit More, Lift & Look, bagel, frozenCPT-160P1 Metal Classic: $37.49; 900 W, 1.5 in slots, 6 shades
4-sliceBTA730XL “A Bit More” long-slot 4-slice: $119.95; 1800 W, 2 long slotsCPT-180P1 Metal Classic: $52.49; 1800 W, 4 x 1.5 in slots, two dials
Bread presetsBTA735 Toast Select Luxe: $219.95; 6 presets (whole wheat, white, bagel, waffles, pastries, English muffin)CPT-640P1 Custom Select 4-slice: $79.95; presets for bread, bagel, English muffin, frozen waffle, pastry
MotorizedBTA820XL Die-Cast 2-slice: $199.95; die-cast aluminum, 1.5 x 5.5 in slotsCPT-525 Motorized Digital 2-slice: $99.95; 6 presets, Memory Set
Motorized 4-sliceBTA830XL Die-Cast long-slot: $219.95; BTA840XL 4-slice: $247.42 (third-party seller)CPT-545: $149.99
Countdown timerLED progress bar on every modelCPT-435P1: $74.95; backlit LCD countdown
Warranty1-year limitedLimited 3-year

Where Breville Wins

  • “A Bit More” and Lift & Look. Every current US Breville toaster has both buttons: one adds a short burst of extra time, the other raises the bread to check it without cancelling the cycle. Cuisinart has no equivalent.
  • Long slots. The BTA730XL takes long slices in two long slots. Cuisinart’s current lineup has no long-slot toaster.
  • Build. The Die-Cast models use a die-cast aluminum body. Cuisinart’s metal toasters are stainless steel, and its Compact line is plastic.

Where Cuisinart Wins

  • Price. Cuisinart’s 4-slice CPT-180P1 costs less than half the cheapest Breville.
  • Warranty. Limited 3 years against Breville’s 1 year.
  • Motorized for less. The CPT-525 does the same motorized lowering as Breville’s Die-Cast for $100 less.
  • Independent slot pairs. The CPT-180P1 and CPT-435P1 have separate controls for each pair of slots.

Which Should You Buy?

  • Buy Breville if you want long slots, the Bit More and Lift & Look buttons, or a die-cast build, and you’re fine with a 1-year warranty. The BTA720XL ($109.95) is the one to start with.
  • Buy Cuisinart if you want a solid toaster for under $80 with a 3-year warranty. The CPT-180P1 ($52.49) covers most households.

Best breville to start with

Breville BTA720XL Bit More 2-Slice Toaster

Brushed stainless 2-slice with A Bit More, Lift and Look, bagel and frozen buttons and an LED progress bar.

Best cuisinart value

Cuisinart CPT-180P1 4-Slice Metal Classic Toaster

1800 W stainless 4-slice toaster with 1.5-inch slots, two independent 6-setting dials and a 3-year limited warranty.

Breville vs. Cuisinart FAQ

Is a Breville toaster worth the extra money over Cuisinart?

Only if you’ll use what Cuisinart lacks: long slots, the A Bit More and Lift & Look buttons, or a die-cast body. For plain toast and bagels, Cuisinart’s 1.5-inch-slot models cover the same ground for less and with a longer warranty.

Which has the longer warranty, Breville or Cuisinart?

Cuisinart. Its retail toasters have a limited 3-year warranty. Breville’s US toasters have a 1-year limited warranty.

Do Breville or Cuisinart make a motorized toaster?

Both do. Breville’s Die-Cast Smart Toasters (BTA820XL, BTA830XL, BTA840XL) lower the bread automatically, and so do Cuisinart’s CPT-525 and CPT-545.

Is there a Breville “Lift and Look” toaster?

Not anymore. Breville’s US ‘Lift and Look’ Touch (BTA630), a 4-slice long-slot toaster with 1-touch lowering, is discontinued. Lift & Look is now a button on every current US Breville toaster. In Australia, the BTA720 is sold as the “Lift & Look Pro.”

Sources