The short answer: for thick, long sourdough slices, buy a long-slot toaster with wide slots, such as the Breville BTA730XL ($119.95). For thick but standard-size slices like Texas toast, a toaster with published 1.5-inch slots is enough, such as the Cuisinart CPT-180P1 ($52.49) or KitchenAid KMT2115 ($47.99). Avoid two premium toasters for thick bread: Revolution’s slots are only about 1 inch wide, and Dualit’s manual says slices thicker than 28 mm (1.1 inches) will jam.

Prices checked November 19, 2026, on Amazon.

Slot Width and Length by Model

ModelSlot widthSlot lengthPriceNotes
Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast 2-slice1.5 in5.5 in$199.95Motorized lowering
Cuisinart CPT-180P1 / CPT-160P1 / CPT-1221.5 inn/s$52.49 / $37.49 / —4-slot / 2-slot / compact
KitchenAid KMT2115 / KMT41151.5 inn/s$47.99 / $69.99All-metal
Smeg TSF01 / TSF02 / TSF031.4 inn/s$159.98 and upTSF02 has long slots
Bella 4-Slice Slim“Wide”10 in$29.99Two long slots
Dash Clear ViewAbout 1.5 in (Dash support)10 in (Amazon listing)$43.99One long slot
Breville BTA730XL“Extra wide” (n/s)Long (n/s)$119.95Two long slots
Dualit ClassicMax slice 28 mm (1.1 in)n/s$324.95Jams above 28 mm
Revolution R180 Connect PlusAbout 1 inAbout 5.25 in$359.95Manual: nothing thicker than 1 in

“n/s” = not stated by the maker. Widths are from maker spec sheets and manuals, except Breville’s Die-Cast (Williams-Sonoma’s listing) and Dash (Dash support answers on Target). More models are on our toaster slot sizes page.

Best for Sourdough: Breville BTA730XL

Best for sourdough

Breville BTA730XL Bit More 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster

Two long, extra-wide slots for long sourdough slices or 4 sandwich slices, with Lift & Look and A Bit More. $119.95.

A long oval slice of sourdough doesn’t fit a standard 5- to 6-inch slot without cutting it in half. The BTA730XL’s two long slots take one long slice each, and Breville describes them as extra wide. Lift & Look helps here: thick slices take longer and brown less predictably, so checking mid-cycle saves a burnt crust.

Best 4-Slot for Thick Slices: Cuisinart CPT-180P1

Best 4-slot for thick slices

Cuisinart CPT-180P1 4-Slice Metal Classic Toaster

Four 1.5-inch slots with two independent 6-setting dials, bagel, defrost and reheat. 3-year limited warranty. $52.49.

Four 1.5-inch slots and two independent dials, so thick slices on one side can run darker than thin ones on the other. Cuisinart’s manual tip: very fresh or whole wheat bread needs a higher setting than normal, and uneven toasting is usually caused by slices of uneven thickness.

Best 2-Slot: KitchenAid KMT2115

Best 2-slot for thick slices

KitchenAid KMT2115SX 2-Slice Toaster

1.5-inch slots, an extra-deep steel toasting cavity, 5 shades, bagel and frozen settings and manual high lift. $47.99.

KitchenAid publishes 1.5-inch slots and an “extra-deep” steel toasting cavity for the KMT2115. It’s all metal, 900 W, with a manual high-lift lever and a replacement warranty.

Best Under $30: Bella 4-Slice Slim

Best under $30

Bella Fits-Anywhere 4-Slice Slim Toaster

Two 10-inch long, wide slots Bella says fit thick bagels, sourdough and baguettes. 6 shades, bagel preset. $29.99.

Bella says its 10-inch slots are “roomy enough for thick bagels, slices of sourdough bread or even baguettes.” It’s only 3.58 inches wide, with 6 shades, a bagel preset, defrost, cancel and a high-lift lever.

Best Automatic: Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast

Best automatic

Breville BTA820XL Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster

1.5 x 5.5 inch slots with motorized lowering and lifting, Lift & Look and A Bit More. Die-cast aluminum. $199.95.

The Die-Cast BTA820XL’s slots measure 1.5 x 5.5 inches, and a motor lowers and lifts the bread, which helps with thick slices that stick in a manual carriage. It’s the expensive way to get 1.5-inch slots.

Toasters to Avoid for Thick Bread

  • Revolution (R90, R180 Connect, Connect Plus). Revolution’s FAQ gives the Connect Plus slots as about 1 inch wide and 5.25 inches long, and its manuals say not to toast foods thicker than 1 inch. See is the Revolution toaster worth it?
  • Dualit Classic. Dualit’s US manual warns that slices thicker than 28 mm (about 1.1 inches) will get stuck.
  • Smeg slots are 1.4 inches, slightly narrower than Cuisinart’s and KitchenAid’s 1.5 inches.

Thick Bread Toaster FAQ

What is the best toaster for thick slices of bread?

A toaster with published 1.5-inch slots: the Cuisinart CPT-180P1 ($52.49), KitchenAid KMT2115 ($47.99) or Breville Die-Cast BTA820XL ($199.95). For long sourdough slices, a long-slot model like the Breville BTA730XL ($119.95).

How wide should toaster slots be for Texas toast?

About 1.5 inches. Texas toast is cut thicker than sandwich bread, and 1.5 inches is the widest slot most home toaster makers publish.

Why does thick bread toast unevenly?

Thick slices take longer to dry out and brown, and slices that aren’t the same thickness top to bottom brown unevenly. Cuisinart’s manual names uneven slice thickness as the usual cause of uneven toast. See why a toaster toasts unevenly.

Should I force a thick slice into a toaster?

No. Cuisinart’s manual says foods should fit freely between the guide wires; forcing bread in can jam the carriage or touch the elements.

Sources