The short answer: the KitchenAid KMT2115 is the best toaster for bagels under $50. It has 1.5-inch slots, a bagel mode that halves the power to one side so the crust stays soft, and a high-lift lever for English muffins, for $47.99. For a family, the Cuisinart CPT-180P1 ($52.49) gives four 1.5-inch slots with independent bagel buttons. For presets that set the time for bagels and English muffins separately, the Cuisinart CPT-640P1 ($79.95).
Prices checked November 19, 2026, on Amazon.
What Makes a Toaster Good for Bagels
- Slot width of about 1.5 inches. A bagel half is thick; narrow slots squeeze it or won’t take it at all. Cuisinart, KitchenAid and Breville’s Die-Cast publish 1.5 inches. Smeg is 1.4 inches. Revolution’s slots are about 1 inch, too narrow for most bagels.
- A real bagel mode. It should toast the cut side and only warm the crust. Makers do it differently (table below).
- A high-lift lever to get English muffin halves and small bagels out without tongs.
- A frozen or defrost setting, because many people keep bagels in the freezer.
Bagel Toasters Compared
| Model | Price | Slot width | How the bagel mode works | High lift | Frozen / defrost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| KitchenAid KMT2115 | $47.99 | 1.5 in | Cuts one side’s power by 50% | Yes, manual | Yes |
| Cuisinart CPT-180P1 (4-slice) | $52.49 | 1.5 in | Bagel button per pair of slots | n/s | Yes |
| Cuisinart CPT-640P1 Custom Select | $79.95 | 1.5 in (Custom Select line) | Bagel and English muffin presets; reduces heat on one side | Extra-lift | Yes |
| Hamilton Beach 22633 | $29.95 | “Extra-wide” (n/s) | Toasts the cut side only | Toast Boost | Yes |
| Breville BTA720XL ‘A Bit More’ | $109.95 | “Extra wide and deep” (n/s) | Bagel mode | Lift & Look | Frozen |
| Breville BTA735 Toast Select Luxe | $219.95 | “Wider slots” (n/s) | Bagel and English Muffin presets | Lift & Look | n/s |
“n/s” = not stated by the maker.
Best Under $50: KitchenAid KMT2115
Best for bagels under $50
KitchenAid KMT2115SX 2-Slice Toaster
1.5-inch slots, a bagel mode that halves one side's power, frozen setting and a manual high-lift lever. All metal. $47.99.
KitchenAid’s spec sheet says its bagel setting “cuts the power to one side by 50%,” so the cut side browns while the crust stays soft. The 1.5-inch slots take bagel halves without squeezing, and the manual high-lift lever raises English muffins clear of the slot. It has a steel toasting cavity, 5 shades, frozen/defrost and cancel, at 900 W.
Best for Families: Cuisinart CPT-180P1
Best for families
Cuisinart CPT-180P1 4-Slice Metal Classic Toaster
Four 1.5-inch slots, two independent dials, and bagel, defrost and reheat buttons for each pair. 3-year warranty. $52.49.
The CPT-180P1 has a bagel button for each pair of slots, so two bagels and two slices of toast can run at the same time on different settings. All four slots are 1.5 inches wide, and each side has its own 6-setting dial and defrost button. Cuisinart’s limited warranty is 3 years.
Best Presets: Cuisinart CPT-640P1 Custom Select
Best presets
Cuisinart CPT-640P1 4-Slice Custom Select Toaster
Separate bagel and English muffin presets, plus bread, waffle and pastry, with 7 shades and single-slice mode. $79.95.
Custom Select toasters set the time by food type. Cuisinart’s manual lists separate Bagel and English Muffin settings, a 1-to-7 shade slider, defrost, single slice and an extra-lift lever. It also explains how its bagel mode works: it “reduces heat on one side of the toasting slot,” and an icon on top shows which way the cut side faces.
Best Under $30: Hamilton Beach 22633
Best under $30
Hamilton Beach 22633 Extra-Wide Slot 2-Slice Toaster
Extra-wide slots, a bagel setting that toasts only the cut side, defrost and Toast Boost for English muffins. $29.95.
Hamilton Beach’s bagel setting toasts the cut side only, and Toast Boost raises small items like English muffins higher for removal. It has 7 shades, defrost and cancel, at 850 W. Hamilton Beach calls the slots “extra-wide” but doesn’t give a measurement.
Best Upgrade: Breville BTA720XL
Best upgrade
Breville BTA720XL Bit More Toaster, 2-Slice
Bagel and frozen modes, Lift & Look to check browning mid-cycle and A Bit More for a short top-up. $109.95.
Breville’s ‘A Bit More’ adds two things that help with bagels: Lift & Look, to check the cut side without cancelling, and A Bit More, to add a little time without a full second cycle. It has bagel and frozen modes and “extra wide and deep” slots.
Bagel Toaster FAQ
What slot width do I need for bagels?
About 1.5 inches. That’s the width Cuisinart and KitchenAid publish for their toasters, and Breville’s Die-Cast measures 1.5 x 5.5 inches. Our toaster slot sizes page lists every published width.
What does the bagel setting on a toaster do?
It toasts the cut side more than the crust. Hamilton Beach and Smeg toast only one side; KitchenAid cuts one side’s power by 50%; Cuisinart reduces heat on one side of each slot. Put the cut side facing the side that stays on, which the toaster’s icon or manual shows.
What is the best toaster for English muffins?
One with a high-lift lever and an English muffin or bagel setting. The Cuisinart CPT-640P1 and Breville BTA735 Toast Select Luxe have English muffin presets; the KitchenAid KMT2115 and Hamilton Beach 22633 lift small items high.
Can I toast frozen bagels?
Yes, with the defrost or frozen setting, which adds time to thaw before toasting. Cuisinart’s manual says to choose Bagel, set the shade, lower the lever and then press Defrost.










