The short answer: the Smeg TSF01 is the best retro toaster for most kitchens, and the Dualit Classic is the one to buy if you want it to last for decades. The Smeg ($159.98 in black, $229.95 in stainless) has the 50s look in many colors, 1.4-inch slots and 6 browning levels. The Dualit ($324.95) is hand-built in the UK with replaceable elements, but it has a mechanical timer and doesn’t pop up. For a chrome retro look under $65, the Hamilton Beach 24721.
Prices checked November 19, 2026, on Amazon.
Retro Toasters Compared
| Model | Price | Slots | Watts | Functions | Made in | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Smeg TSF01 (2-slice) | $159.98 black; $229.95 stainless | 2 x 1.4 in | 980 W | 6 levels, defrost, reheat, one-side bagel | China (Sur La Table) | 1 yr |
| Smeg TSF03 (4x4) | $209.95 | 4 x 1.4 in, 2 control panels | 1,800 W (spec table) | Same, per side | China (Sur La Table) | 1 yr |
| Smeg TSF02 (2 long slots) | $279.95 (third-party) | 2 long x 1.4 in | 1,400 W | Same | n/s | 1 yr |
| Dualit Classic 2-slice NewGen | $324.95 | 2, max slice 28 mm | 1,200 W | Mechanical timer, manual eject, bagel (NewGen) | UK (hand-built) | 1 yr |
| Hamilton Beach 24721 Retro | $60.95 | 4, “wide” | n/s | Sure-Toast | n/s | 1 yr |
Smeg’s TSF03 page lists 1,800 W in its spec table and 2,000 W in its description. “n/s” = not stated.
Best Overall: Smeg TSF01
Best retro toaster
Smeg TSF01 2-Slice Toaster, Black
50s-style steel 2-slice: 980 W, 1.4-inch slots, 6 browning levels, defrost, reheat and one-side bagel. $159.98 in black.
The TSF01 has a rounded 50s-style steel body with a polished chrome base and top. It has two 1.4-inch slots, 6 browning levels, defrost, reheat, a bagel mode that toasts one side, backlit controls and a polished stainless crumb tray.
How to read Smeg model codes: US models end in “US,” with the color before it: TSF01CRUS is cream, BL black, PG pastel green, RD red, WH white, SS stainless. Codes ending in UK, EU or AU are 220–240 V versions that won’t work properly on US power.
Price depends on color. On Amazon on November 19, black was $159.98, while stainless and matte champagne were about $230. Smeg’s own US price is $275. The Dolce & Gabbana “Sicily is My Love” edition (TSF01DGUS) is $950 with the same specs.
Best 4-Slice Retro: Smeg TSF03
Best 4-slice retro
Smeg TSF03 4-Slice Toaster, Stainless Steel
Retro 4x4 toaster with four 1.4-inch slots, two independent control panels, 6 levels, defrost, reheat and bagel. $209.95.
The TSF03 has four short slots with two independent control panels, so it works as two toasters. Smeg’s other 4-slice, the TSF02, has two long slots instead, for long artisan slices. Both list at $330 on smeg.com; the TSF03 was $209.95 from Amazon on November 19. See Smeg 2-slice vs. 4-slice.
Best for Decades of Use: Dualit Classic
Best for decades of use
Dualit Classic 2-Slice NewGen Toaster
Hand-built in the UK with replaceable ProHeat elements, a mechanical timer and manual eject. $324.95, sold by Sur La Table.
Dualit says each Classic is hand-made in the UK with the assembler’s name on the base. Its ProHeat elements and timer are replaceable parts; see can you repair a Dualit toaster?
It doesn’t behave like a modern toaster. The timer is mechanical, the toast doesn’t pop up (you turn the ejector knob), and Dualit’s manual says slices thicker than 28 mm will get stuck. The NewGen version adds a bagel setting. Dualit’s US warranty is 1 year. See Smeg vs. Dualit.
Best Budget Retro: Hamilton Beach 24721
Best budget retro
Hamilton Beach 24721 Retro 4-Slice Toaster
Chrome retro-style 4-slice with wide slots and Sure-Toast technology. $60.95.
A retro-styled chrome 4-slice with wide slots and Hamilton Beach’s Sure-Toast technology, for $60.95. Hamilton Beach doesn’t publish its wattage or slot width, and its US warranty is 1 year.
Retro Toaster FAQ
What is the best retro toaster?
The Smeg TSF01 for most kitchens: 50s styling, 1.4-inch slots, 6 browning levels and several colors from $159.98. The Dualit Classic ($324.95) if you want a repairable toaster built to last.
Is the Smeg toaster worth it?
You pay for design: the TSF01 has the same core functions as a $50 toaster (defrost, reheat, bagel) and a 1-year US warranty. See is the Smeg toaster worth it?
Where are Smeg and Dualit toasters made?
Sur La Table lists Smeg’s TSF01 and TSF03 as made in China. Dualit says its Classic toasters are hand-made in the UK; it doesn’t state an origin for its other lines.
How long is the Smeg toaster warranty in the US?
One year, limited. Smeg adds a second year only for purchases from its online store, smegstore.us. The 2-year figures on Smeg’s UK and EU sites don’t apply in the US.









