The short answer: the KitchenAid KMT2115 is the best choice for a toaster with no plastic or coatings where the bread goes. KitchenAid’s spec sheet describes “all-metal construction” and an “extra-deep, steel toasting cavity,” and it costs $47.99. The Dualit Classic ($324.95) is stainless steel and die-cast aluminum and is built to be repaired. One caveat applies to every pop-up toaster: no maker publishes what, if anything, coats the inside of the toasting chamber, so a “non-toxic” claim beyond what’s below can’t be verified.
Prices checked November 19, 2026, on Amazon.
What Each Maker Says About Materials
| Model | What the maker states | Plastic parts mentioned | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| KitchenAid KMT2115 / KMT4115 | “All-metal construction,” “extra-deep, steel toasting cavity” | None stated | $47.99 / $69.99 |
| Dualit Classic | “Stainless steel and die-cast aluminium,” replaceable ProHeat elements | None stated | $324.95 |
| Cuisinart Custom Select (CPT-620P1, CPT-640P1) | “All materials that come in contact with food are BPA free” | n/s | $39.95 / $79.95 |
| Cuisinart CPT-160P1 / CPT-180P1 | Stainless steel body (“Metal Classic”) | n/s | $37.49 / $52.49 |
| Breville BTA820XL / BTA830XL Die-Cast | “Die-Cast Aluminum” body | n/s | $199.95 / $219.95 |
| Breville BTA720XL / BTA730XL | “Brushed Stainless Steel” body | n/s | $109.95 / $119.95 |
| Smeg TSF01 | Steel body, polished chrome base and top, polished stainless crumb tray | n/s | $159.98 |
| Smeg TSF02 / TSF03 | Steel body and top, polished stainless crumb tray | Plastic base, knob and buttons | $279.95 / $209.95 |
| Dualit Architect / Design Series | “Stainless and polymer” | Polymer | $298.95 |
| Hamilton Beach, Black+Decker, Oster, Dash, Revolution | Interior material not stated | n/s | — |
“n/s” = not stated. Materials quotes are from the makers’ spec sheets, manuals and product pages.
Best Overall: KitchenAid KMT2115
Best non-toxic toaster
KitchenAid KMT2115SX 2-Slice Toaster, Brushed Stainless
All-metal construction with an extra-deep steel toasting cavity, per KitchenAid's spec sheet. 1.5-inch slots. $47.99.
KitchenAid is the only mainstream maker whose spec sheet says both the body (“all-metal construction”) and the toasting cavity (“steel”) are metal. The brushed stainless KMT2115SX costs the same $47.99 as the painted colors on Amazon. For four slices, the KMT4115 has the same all-metal description for $69.99.
Best Built to Last: Dualit Classic
Best built to last
Dualit Classic 2-Slice NewGen Toaster
Stainless steel and die-cast aluminum, hand-built in the UK, with replaceable elements and timer. $324.95.
Dualit describes the Classic as “stainless steel and die-cast aluminium” and sells its elements and timer as spare parts, so it can be repaired rather than thrown away. Dualit’s cheaper Architect and Lite lines are “stainless and polymer.” The Classic doesn’t pop up (you turn an ejector knob), and slices thicker than 28 mm will stick.
Best BPA-Free Statement: Cuisinart CPT-640P1 Custom Select
Best BPA-free statement
Cuisinart CPT-640P1 4-Slice Custom Select Toaster
Stainless 4-slice; Cuisinart's Custom Select manual says all food-contact materials are BPA free. Presets, 7 shades. $79.95.
Cuisinart’s Custom Select manual is the only pop-up toaster document we found that makes a statement about food-contact parts: “All materials that come in contact with food are BPA free.” That’s narrower than “no plastic,” but it’s a written claim. The CPT-640P1 is the 4-slice Custom Select; the 2-slice CPT-620P1 is $39.95.
What “Non-Toxic” Can and Can’t Mean for a Toaster
- A pop-up toaster’s bread doesn’t touch a coated pan. The bread sits between metal guide wires next to the heating elements. The materials question is mostly about the cavity walls and wires, which no maker fully discloses.
- Plastic outside the cavity is common. Smeg’s own spec tables list a plastic base on the TSF02 and TSF03, and plastic knobs and buttons.
- PFAS claims belong to toaster ovens, not pop-up toasters. Cuisinart’s “NAS” toaster ovens say “no intentionally added PFAS,” and Breville’s oven manuals mention a non-stick interior coating. No pop-up maker makes a PFAS statement either way. See are non-stick toaster ovens safe?
- Burnt toast is a separate issue. Acrylamide forms as bread browns, whatever toaster you use. See is burnt toast bad for you?
Non-Toxic Toaster FAQ
Is there a toaster with no plastic at all?
No maker of a current pop-up toaster states that its toaster contains no plastic anywhere. KitchenAid’s KMT2115 and KMT4115 are described as all-metal with a steel toasting cavity, the closest written claim. Internal wiring insulation and controls aren’t covered by any maker’s statement.
Are stainless steel toasters non-toxic?
A stainless body says nothing about the inside. KitchenAid is the only mainstream maker that also says its toasting cavity is steel.
Do toasters have Teflon or PFAS?
No pop-up toaster maker in our research publishes an interior coating, so it can’t be confirmed either way. PFAS-free claims exist for some toaster ovens (Cuisinart NAS models, Ninja FO100/FO101, Panasonic NB-G211P).
Are toaster bags non-toxic?
Reusable toaster bags are commonly sold as PTFE, which is a PFAS; the Amazon listing we checked describes its bags as “Non-Stick PTFE.” See are toaster bags safe?








