The short answer: the Hamilton Beach 22633 ($29.95) is the best toaster under $30, and the Cuisinart CPT-160P1 ($37.49) is the best under $50. The Hamilton Beach has extra-wide slots, 7 shades and a cut-side bagel mode. The Cuisinart adds a stainless body, 1.5-inch slots and a 3-year limited warranty, three times the coverage of most toasters at any price. If you want all metal, the KitchenAid KMT2115 ($47.99) just fits under $50.

Prices checked November 19, 2026, on Amazon (all sold by Amazon).

Cheap Toasters Compared

ModelPriceSlotsSlot widthShadesBagel / defrostWattsWarranty
Proctor Silex 22305$22.952“Extra wide”n/sBageln/sn/s
Amazon Basics TA01318B-UL$24.292“Extra wide”7Yes / yesn/sn/s
Hamilton Beach 22633$29.952“Extra wide”7Cut side only / yes850 W1 yr
Bella 4-Slice Slim$29.992 long (4 slices)10 in long6Preset / yesn/sn/s
Cuisinart CPT-160P1$37.4921.5 in6Yes / yes900 W3 yr limited
Dash Clear View$43.991 long (2 slices)About 1.5 in7Yes / yes1,100 W1 yr (2 registered)
KitchenAid KMT2115$47.9921.5 in5One side at 50% / yes900 W1 yr, replacement

Proctor Silex and Amazon Basics details are from their Amazon listings; the rest are from maker pages and manuals. “n/s” = not stated.

Best Under $30: Hamilton Beach 22633

Best under $30

Hamilton Beach 22633 Extra-Wide Slot 2-Slice Toaster

850 W, extra-wide slots, 7 shades, cut-side bagel mode, defrost, cancel and Toast Boost. $29.95.

The 22633 has the functions you’d want from a $100 toaster: 7 shades, a bagel setting that toasts only the cut side, defrost, cancel, auto shutoff and Toast Boost, which lifts small items like English muffins higher. Hamilton Beach’s US warranty is 1 year, and the owner pays shipping both ways for a claim.

Best Under $50: Cuisinart CPT-160P1

Best under $50

Cuisinart CPT-160P1 2-Slice Metal Classic Toaster

Stainless 2-slice with 1.5-inch slots, 6 shades, bagel, defrost, reheat and extra-lift lever. 3-year warranty. $37.49.

The CPT-160P1 has a stainless body, 1.5-inch slots, 6 shade settings, defrost, bagel, reheat, an extra-lift lever and a slide-out crumb tray. The reason to spend $7.50 more than the Hamilton Beach is the warranty: Cuisinart’s limited warranty runs 3 years. It’s 10.75 x 7.13 x 7.13 inches.

Best All-Metal Under $50: KitchenAid KMT2115

Best all-metal under $50

KitchenAid KMT2115SX 2-Slice Toaster

All-metal 2-slice with a steel toasting cavity, 1.5-inch slots, 5 shades, bagel, frozen and high lift. $47.99.

KitchenAid’s spec sheet calls the KMT2115 “all-metal” with a steel toasting cavity. It has 1.5-inch slots, 5 shades, bagel, frozen/defrost and a manual high-lift lever, and KitchenAid replaces it rather than repairing it during the 1-year warranty. Abt’s list price for it is $79.95.

Best Long-Slot Under $30: Bella 4-Slice Slim

Best long-slot under $30

Bella Fits-Anywhere 4-Slice Slim Toaster

Two 10-inch long, wide slots in a 3.58-inch-wide body. 6 shades, bagel preset, defrost, cancel and high lift. $29.99.

Two 10-inch slots fit four sandwich slices or two long sourdough slices, and the body is only 3.58 inches wide. It has 6 shades, a bagel preset, defrost, cancel and a high-lift lever.

Cheapest: Amazon Basics and Proctor Silex

Cheapest with 7 shades

Amazon Basics 2-Slice Toaster, Extra-Wide Slots

Extra-wide slots, 7 browning levels, bagel, defrost and cancel buttons and a removable crumb tray. $24.29.

The Amazon Basics TA01318B-UL lists extra-wide slots, 7 browning levels, bagel, defrost and cancel buttons and a removable crumb tray for $24.29. Proctor Silex (a Hamilton Beach brand) sells the 22305 with extra-wide slots and a bagel setting for $22.95. Neither listing gives a slot width or warranty term, so the Hamilton Beach 22633 is the safer pick for $5 to $7 more.

What You Give Up Under $50

  • Browning controls you can adjust mid-cycle. Breville’s Lift & Look and A Bit More start at $109.95.
  • Motorized lowering. The cheapest is Cuisinart’s CPT-525 at $99.95.
  • Published slot widths. Most budget makers say “extra-wide” without a number. Cuisinart and KitchenAid publish 1.5 inches.
  • Not much else. Every pick here has a bagel setting and defrost, and the Cuisinart’s warranty is longer than any toaster over $100.

Cheap Toaster FAQ

What is the best cheap toaster?

The Hamilton Beach 22633 ($29.95) under $30 and the Cuisinart CPT-160P1 ($37.49) under $50, for its 1.5-inch slots and 3-year limited warranty.

Do cheap toasters last?

Warranty is the best guide to how long a maker expects one to last. Cuisinart covers its $37 to $60 toasters for 3 years, Hamilton Beach and KitchenAid for 1 year. See how long a toaster should last and the most reliable toaster brands.

What is the best 4-slice toaster under $50?

The Bella 4-Slice Slim ($29.99) if long slots work for you. The Cuisinart CPT-180P1, with four 1.5-inch slots and two dials, was $52.49, just over $50.

Are cheap toasters safe?

Look for a safety certification mark (such as UL or ETL) on the rating label. No pop-up toaster recall appears in CPSC’s database from 2020 through November 2026. See toaster recalls.

Sources